STREAMLINED PLATFORM FOR BACTERIAL IDENTIFICATION AND ANTIBIOTIC SUSCEPTIBILITY TEST
20200010874 ยท 2020-01-09
Inventors
- Tza-Huei Jeff Wang (Germantown, MD, US)
- Pornpat Athamanolap (Baltimore, MD, US)
- Liben Chen (Baltimore, MD, US)
- Huangwen Hsieh (Baltimore, MD, US)
Cpc classification
C12Q2545/113
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
B01L2300/0893
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L3/502707
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L3/5027
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
C12Q2563/173
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
B01L7/52
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L2200/0668
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L2300/0864
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
C12Q2563/173
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
B01L3/502761
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
C12Q2545/113
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
International classification
B01L3/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
Abstract
Described are methods for identifying antibiotic resistant bacteria, quantifying bacteria growth, and applying an antibiotic susceptibility test (AST) in one or more biological samples containing a bacteria and chips used in these methods.
Claims
1. A method for identifying and quantifying the growth of antibiotic resistant or sensitive bacteria comprising the steps of: obtaining a biological sample of a subject comprising unidentified bacteria; culturing the unidentified bacteria in a first broth comprising an antibiotic; culturing the unidentified bacteria in a second broth substantially free of the antibiotic; amplifying DNA of the unidentified bacteria in the first and second broth using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) forming amplified DNA that is quantified and correlates with the unidentified bacteria growth; identifying the antibiotic sensitivity or resistance of the unidentified bacteria by comparing the bacteria growth in the first broth with the bacteria growth in the second broth; and identifying the species of unidentified bacteria by determining a first melting curve of the amplified DNA of the unidentified bacteria and comparing it to one or more melting curves of PCR amplicons of known bacteria stored in a computer wherein a species is identified when the first melting curve of the amplified bacteria is equivalent to the one or more melting curves of PCR amplicons stored in the computer.
2. The method of claim 1 comprising a step of separating the unidentified bacteria from the biological sample.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein the biological sample is selected from the group consisting of whole blood, plasma, serum, RBC fraction, urine, saliva, cerebrospinal fluid, semen, sweat, bile, gastric contents, breast milk, exudates, ascites, lymph, sputum, lavage fluid, bronchial fluid, or a combination thereof.
4. The method of claim 1 wherein the biological sample is blood and the method comprises a step of lysing the blood cells but not the unidentified bacteria.
5. The method of claim 1 wherein the culturing the unidentified bacteria is in the range of 15 minutes to 24 hours.
6. The method of claim 1 further comprising the step of identifying the species of unidentified bacteria using high-resolution melt curve analysis (HRMA) to generate the first melting curve of the unidentified bacteria.
7. The method of claim 1 wherein the growth of bacteria is determined by identifying the amount of amplified DNA produced during PCR by generating a fluorescent signal and generating a quantification cycle (Cq) correlated to bacteria growth.
8. The method of claim 1 wherein the unidentified bacteria is antibiotic resistant when Cq differences between the bacteria growth in the first broth and the bacteria growth in the second broth are less than 1.7.
9. The method of claim 1 wherein the unidentified bacteria is antibiotic sensitive when Cq differences between the bacteria growth in the first broth and the bacteria growth in the second broth are more than 1.7.
10. A digital method for identifying and quantifying the growth of antibiotic resistant or sensitive bacteria comprising the steps of: obtaining a biological sample of a subject comprising unidentified bacteria; culturing the unidentified bacteria in a first broth comprising an antibiotic; culturing the unidentified bacteria in a second broth substantially free of the antibiotic; lysing the unidentified bacteria in the first and second broth to release bacteria nucleic acid; diluting the bacteria nucleic acids of unidentified bacteria in first and the second broth and then placing them in two separate arrays of wells so that each well contains no more than one copy of the bacteria nucleic acid; amplifying the bacteria nucleic acid in each well with a mixture including a fluorescent intercalating dye using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) forming amplified DNA; identifying a species of the unidentified bacteria or an identified bacteria species by determining a first melting curve of the amplified DNA in each well and comparing it to one or more melting curves of PCR amplicons of known bacteria stored in a computer wherein a positive identification occurs when the first melting curve of the amplified DNA in the well is equivalent to the one or more melting curves of the PCR amplicons stored in the computer; and identifying the growth of each of the identified bacteria species by determining the amount of bacteria nucleic acid of the identified bacteria species calculated by the number of the wells of the positive identification associated to the identified bacteria species; wherein an identified bacteria species is antibiotic resistant based on the difference of the amount of nucleic acids of the bacteria derived from the first broth and the second.
11. A method for identifying and quantifying the growth of antibiotic resistant or sensitive bacteria comprising the steps of: obtaining a biological sample of a subject comprising unidentified bacteria; mixing the unidentified bacteria in a first broth comprising an antibiotic; mixing the unidentified bacteria in a second broth substantially free of the antibiotic; diluting the unidentified bacteria in the first and second broth and place them in two separate arrays of wells so that each well contains no more than one bacteria; culturing the one bacteria placed in each well forming a colony of one bacteria; lysing the colony of one bacteria to release bacteria nucleic acid; amplifying the bacteria nucleic acid of the colony in each well with a mixture including a fluorescent intercalating dye using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) forming amplified DNA that is quantified and correlates with the unidentified bacteria growth; identifying the species of the unidentified bacteria in each well or an identified bacteria species by determining a first melting curve of the amplified DNA of the unidentified bacteria and comparing it to one or more melting curves of PCR amplicons of known bacteria stored in a computer wherein a positive identification occurs when the first melting curve of the amplified DNA is equivalent to the one or more melting curves of the PCR amplicons stored in the computer; and identifying the growth of each of the identified bacteria species by the average quantification cycle (Cq) derived from the wells of the positive identification associated to the identified bacteria species; wherein an identified bacteria species is antibiotic resistant based on the difference of average Cq of the bacteria derived from the first broth and the second broth.
12. A chip for identifying bacteria, quantifying growth and/or antibiotic resistant or sensitive bacteria comprising: a flow chamber comprising one or more flow channels, microvalves, and picowells wherein the flow channels are in contact with the microvalves and the picowells, the microvalves are located adjacent to the picowells and are capable of being pressurized, enclosing a segment of the flow channel and a picowell, when pressurized, forming a digital reaction chamber.
13. The chip of claim 12 wherein the flow chamber is a microfluidic flow chamber.
14. The method of claim 13 comprising the step of determining the bacterial load of each bacterial species by counting the number of positive identifications (number of wells) of each bacterial species.
15. The chip of claim 12 wherein the microvalves enclose the channels forming digital reaction chambers when the microvalves become pressurized.
16. A method for identifying antibiotic resistant or sensitive bacteria comprising the steps of: a) providing a chip comprising a flow chamber comprising one or more flow channels that are permeable to gas; microvalves, and picowells that are impermeable to gas, wherein the flow channels are in contact with the microvalves and the picowells, the microvalves are located adjacent to the picowells and are capable of being pressurized, and when the microvalves are pressurized they enclose a segment of the flow channel and a picowell forming a digital reaction chamber; b) loading a biological sample comprising bacteria with an antibiotic on to the chip through the one or more flow channels wherein each picowell contains either 0 to 1 bacterial cell; c) injecting fluid into the one or more flow channels but not the picowells; d) culturing the bacteria in the picowells; e) loading a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) mixture on to the chip through the one or more flow channels; f) pressurizing the microvalves enclosing the chambers forming a digital reaction chamber comprising the PCR mixture; g) amplifying DNA of the bacteria using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) forming amplified DNA that is quantified and correlates with the bacteria growth; and h) identifying the antibiotic sensitivity or resistance of the unidentified bacteria by comparing the bacteria growth to a reference bacteria growth.
17. The method of claim 16 further comprising the steps: i) performing melt curve analysis of the amplified DNA; and j) identifying the strain of the bacteria by determining a first melting curve of the bacteria and comparing it to melting curves of one or more known bacteria stored in a computer wherein a positive identification occurs when the first melting curve of the bacteria is equivalent to a second melting curve of a known bacteria.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0028]
[0029]
[0030]
[0031]
[0032]
[0033]
[0034]
[0035]
[0036]
[0037]
[0038]
[0039]
[0040]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0041] Despite the clear need and the research advances to date, there still exist a major technological gap for developing an integrated and streamlined method for identifying infectious bacteria, quantifying bacterial load, and performing antibiotic susceptibility tests (AST) directly from clinical samples. Specifically, methods that can identify and quantify bacteria with high specificity and high sensitivity are based on genetic detection, whereas methods that can perform accurate AST are predominantly based on bacterial growth. These methods are inherently incompatible because genetic detection entails extracting nucleic acids out of the bacteria, rendering downstream AST impossible. To fill this technological gap, in the present invention, a streamlined assay in which the inventors have flipped the order by coupling growth-based AST with highly specific and sensitive genetic detection, thereby achieving a seamless integrated process. In the present invention, bacteria within a sample are first cultivated for a short period in the absence and presence of different antibiotic substances. To detect growth or no growtha hence antibiotic sensitivity or resistancethe bacterial DNA is amplified via real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR) by means of a pair of universal primer. An increase in the DNA amount in the presence of the tested drug shows that the bacteria are phenotypically resistant;
[0042] conversely, no growth in the presence of a drug indicates susceptibility. Precise quantification of bacterial load is readily achieved because each bacterial cell is isolated and detected via qPCR (or digital PCR). Finally, bacteria can be effectively identified via high resolution melt-curve analysis (FIRMA) of PCR amplified DNA, wherein distinct shapes of the melt curves offer effective means for bacteria identification. The method of the present invention can be carried out in both bulk and digital format as is described in this application.
A Streamlined Pathogen Diagnostic Bulk Assay of the Present Invention Integrates ID and AST in a Single Process.
[0043] The inventors have designed an assay protocol to enable combined ID and AST into a single step process (
Isolation of Intact Bacteria from a Large Volume Blood Sample.
[0044] Separating bacterial cells from blood cells and background matrix constituents is critical to detection accuracy. Several existing methods have been developed to clean up samples by removing human cells and proteins; however, they provide non-viable bacterial cells or circulating bacterial DNA for identification though genetic tests, e.g. PCR. While genotypic AST provides a rapid test, it has limited accuracy since the same resistance to an antibiotic agent may be caused by several different mechanisms. Phenotypic AST enables more accurate profiling of bacterial antibiotic susceptibility by direct measurement of cell growth. In order to perform phenotypic AST, the sample preparation method must be able to isolate intact bacterial cells. To this end, the inventors developed a novel sample preparation method for whole blood samples. In the protocol of the present invention (
Comprehensive Diagnostic Assay of Integrated Broad-Scale ID and AST
[0045] The present invention measures bacterial growth by quantifying the bacterial DNA content using qPCR. As proof of concept, the inventors have expanded the use of their previously developed universal primers for PCR.sup.2 to demonstrate the correlation of the bacterial 16S rDNA quantity and the bacterial growth (
[0046] While the typical bacterial doubling time for most of the pathogen ranges from 20 to 60 min, the actual time required for reliable detection of bacterial growth can be longer and is dependent on the sensitivity and resolution of the detection method.
Broad-Scale Pathogen Identification based on HRMA.
[0047] The inventors developed a one-vs-one support vector machine (SVM) algorithm for pathogen identification based on HRMA of the 16S rDNA gene. This technique was implemented for broad-scale pathogen identification after the measurement of bacterial growth. After qPCR, 5 min of temperature ramping was conducted to generate a melt curve, which can be matched with that in the database to determine the target pathogen. The inventors were able to correctly identify the target pathogens (E. coli and S. aureus) by matching the measured melt curves to the previously developed database using the SVM algorithm.sup.2 (
Integrated Broad-Scale ID and AST with High Resolution can be Achieved with Digital PCR (dPCR) for Genetic Analysis of Pathogen DNA.
[0048] Despite the promise of the board scale detection and rapid AST, several limitations remain problematic with the bulk qPCR/HRMA assay. Firstly, qPCR in bulk solution has limited quantification resolution, especially when analyzing low concentration pathogens, and thus it may not be able to reliably detect bacterial growth based on the Cq value. Secondly, polymicrobial or contaminated samples may be misidentified or may give erroneous errors due to the confounded melt curve measured in bulk. These problems can be resolved through digital analysis where each single molecule of bacterial DNA is individually assessed by digital PCR (dPCR) and digital HRMA (dHRMA).
[0049] This method (
[0050] The species of unidentified bacteria is identified by determining a melting curve of PCR amplicons in each chamber and comparing it to the database of melting curves of PCR amplicons of known bacteria stored in a computer wherein a positive identification occurs when the first melting curve of the unidentified bacteria is equivalent to the one or more melting curves of known bacteria stored in the computer.
[0051] The total number of DNA molecules of each species is then quantified by counting the number of reaction chambers of positive identification. Each species will be determined to be antibiotic resistant or sensitive by comparing the number of DNA molecules between the bacteria grown in a broth having an antibiotic and the same bacteria grown in a broth without an antibiotic. The inventors have conducted a proof-of-concept experiment by mixing sensitive strains of S. aureus and E. faecalis and incubating them for 2 hours with and without 8 g/mL of gentamicin. Bacterial DNA was extracted and diluted 60000-fold such that either 0 or 1 copy of DNA was loaded into each well of a 96-well microtiter plate. Following PCR and HRMA, species identification was performed on the melting curves from both with and without gentamicin-treated plates. The counted of both species with no-gentamicin controls were greater than gentamicin-treated samples by approximately 3-5 folds indicating that gentamicin had effectively inhibited the growth of both bacteria (
[0052] By investigating a single molecule of bacterial DNA, heterogeneous sub-populations can be differentiated and quantified, which enables combined ID/AST assay for coinfection detection and also allows for distinguishing whether a detected molecule is a true pathogen or contaminant in instances where it could be either. Furthermore, counting individual molecules improves detection sensitivity, which can potentially reduce the required incubation time in order to detect bacterial growth.
Integrated ID and AST with Single-Cell Resolution can be Achieved with a Large Number of Digital (Single-Cell) Reaction Chambers for Culture, and Genetic Analysis of Pathogens.
[0053] This combined ID/AST assay can be further implemented to perform single-cell analysis where an array of digital reaction chambers is used for identifying and quantifying the growth of individual cells. Encapsulating a single cell in the small volume leads to confinement of bacterial DNA of a high concentration. The high DNA concentration facilitates unambiguous detection of bacterial replications to determine the antibiotic susceptibility. Furthermore, since the melt curve is measured at the single-cell resolution, heterogeneous sub-populations can be differentiated and quantified. Additionally, the single-cell analysis enables absolute quantification of bacterial load without the need for calibration.
[0054] The method (
[0055] The species of unidentified bacteria is identified by determining a melting curve of PCR amplicons in each chamber and comparing it to the database of melting curves of PCR amplicons of known bacteria stored in a computer wherein a positive identification occurs when the first melting curve of the unidentified bacteria is equivalent to the one or more melting curves of known bacteria stored in the computer.
[0056] The bacterial load of each species is quantified by counting the number of reaction chamber of positive identification.
[0057] Importantly, Cq of PCR in each chamber represents the quantity of bacterial DNA, which relates to growth of each bacterial cell. Therefore, each bacterial species will be determined to be antibiotic resistant or sensitive by comparing the average Cq number of the reaction chambers of positive identification corresponding to the species between the bacteria grown in a broth having an antibiotic and the same bacteria grown in a broth without an antibiotic.
Integrated ID and AST with Single-Cell Resolution can be Achieved with a Novel Microfluidic Chip for Digitization, Culture, and Genetic Analysis of Pathogens.
[0058] To facilitate ID/AST assay at single cell resolution, the inventors have conceptually developed a novel microfluidic chip that realizes this concept of digital assay. The inventors will demonstrate rapid and massively parallelized assessment of single-cell culture, growth measurement via qPCR for quantification of bacterial DNA and strain identification via HRMA.
[0059] The inventors have developed conceptually a novel Microfluidic Dual-Digital Array (MD.sup.2A) chip that utilizes a facile approach to integrate bacteria loading, digitization, culture, reagent switching, PCR, and melt curve analysis in a monolithic device (
Fabrication of MD.SUP.2.A Chip.
[0060] The main material for the MD.sup.2A chip will be polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS). The device is composed of a fluidic channel and picowell layer and a microvalve network layer. The fabrication of a device with these layers will be achieved using a modified multilayer soft lithography technique as we have demonstrated in the past (H. Zec, C. O'Keefe, P. Ma and T. H. Wang, Ultra-thin, evaporation-resistent PDMS devices for absolute quantification of DNA using digital PCR, 2015 Transducers2015 18th International Conference on Solid-State Sensors, Actuators and Microsystems (TRANSDUCERS), Anchorage, Ak., 2015, pp. 536-539. doi: 10.1109/TRANSDUCERS.2015.7180979). Briefly, molds for the fluid layer and the microvalve layer will be microfabricated on separate silicon wafers via photolithography. Replicas of these molds are then generated using PDMS casting on the molds. The fluidic and microvalve layer replicas are then aligned and thermally bonded in an oven to generate a single chip. Holes are punched in this chip at input and output ports for making fluidic connections with the chip. Finally the bottom surface of the device (containing the microvalve layer) is bonded to a cover glass, readying the chip for experiments.
[0061] In one embodiment of the present invention the inventors have designed and fabricated an array chip that contains four identical units, each housing 960 picowells (250 pL in volume) that are connected through inlet/outlet branching channels (
Sample Loading, Digitization, and Reagent Exchange.
[0062] The present invention provides a robust process for sample loading, digitization, and reagent exchange (
MD.SUP.2.A Assay and Data Analysis.
[0063] One embodiment of MD.sup.2A chips and assays of the present invention include chips that house 1000 picowells/digital chambers. S. aureus will first be used as the model bacteria. Fixed input S. aureus concentration (e.g., 110.sup.6 CFU/mL) and digitally culturing S. aureus cells will be used with a fixed culturing time (e.g., 2 hours), and finally PCR mix will be injected and PCR and HRMA performed using the PCR reagents and primers disclosed. Using the inventors' custom-built optical detection instrument, the inventors are able to acquire fluorescent images of the MD.sup.2A chip at each PCR cycle, as well as at each temperature point during the melt curve experiment. Custom MATLAB programs are being developed to measure the fluorescence intensities within each digital chamber over the course of PCR and melt curve experiment.
[0064] A data analysis protocol for PCR will be formed by first plot fluorescence intensity-based real-time PCR curves for all isolated (digital) chambers and measure the Cq values for the chambers with amplified PCR products. The total number of chambers with high fluorescence intensities at the end of PCR allows the inventors to count the initial concentration of S. aureus. A data analysis protocol for HRMA, will be formed by focusing on digital chambers with amplified PCR products and plot the melt curves and acquire the melt signature (e.g., peak temperature values or peak heights) of S. aureus. For PCR and FIRMA results, the inventors can average the Cq values and melt curves across the entire MD.sup.2A chip. Alternatively, the inventors can also plot the Cq values and melt signatures into histograms for statistical analysis and understanding the population distribution.
[0065] After establishing a baseline analyses, the inventors will vary the input S. aureus concentrations, the culturing time, and will also add antibiotics (e.g., penicillin) to the sample.
[0066] With the changes to the input S. aureus concentrations, the inventors will count different numbers of digital chambers with high fluorescence intensities and they will verify that they are able to still correctly measure the number of digital chambers in accordance to Poisson distribution. As the culturing time increases, the inventors will measure decreased average Cq value from the MD.sup.2A chip after PCR. Finally, with the addition of a high concentration of antibiotic that will inhibit S. aureus growth, the inventors will measure a high average Cq value from the MD.sup.2A chip after PCR.
Optimization of MD.SUP.2.A Chip and Assay.
[0067] To analyze single cells with a wide dynamic range and test numerous antibiotic conditions, MD.sup.2A chip will harbor a massive number of picowells/digital chambers. The number and volume of picowells will also support the input sample volume (20-50 L) from concentrated cells prepared by the upstream blood processing methods. The number of picowells could be in the range of thousands to millions of wells. Furthermore, the chip will be divided into multiple units for AST at different drug conditions. For example, the design of 25 units will allow testing of 6 drugs at 4 concentrations in addition to a no-drug control. On the other hand, the massive array of picowells/digital chambers still must fit within the imaging area of the optical detection instrument (32.9 by 43.8 mm). Therefore, we will extensively optimize the MD.sup.2A chip and assay.
[0068] Specifically, the inventors will optimize the volumes the picowells and the digital reaction chambers, as well as the dimensions for the microvalves and pitches. The inventors will also optimize the conditions of their digital PCR process. We will continue working with S. aureus in these optimization experiments. We will initially design 25-pL picowells (e.g., 50 m (L) by 20 m (W) by 25 m (H)), isolate single S. aureus cells (equivalent to 410.sup.7 cells/mL), and verify that these picowells still retain sufficient culture broth and will support S. aureus growth. The digital reaction chambers will be 500 pL (e.g., 100 m (L) by 200 m (W) by 25 m (H), or 20-fold greater than the picowells in volume. The results demonstrate that single S. aureus cell PCR can be reliably achieved at such volume (
Validation with Multiple Bacteria and Antibiotics.
[0069] To validate our MD.sup.2A chip and assay, the inventors will detect and quantify 4 reference strains of bacteria and measure their resistance to 6 representative antibiotics. Following the CLSI guideline, the inventors will culture E. coli with ampicillin and gentamicin, S. aureus with penicillin and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, P. aeruginosa with ceftazidime and gentamicin, and E. faecalis with ampicillin and penicillin. For each pair of bacteria and antibiotic, the inventors will perform a no-antibiotic control and test a high antibiotic concentration that will inhibit bacterial growth. In these experiments, the no-antibiotic control will yield low Cq values, whereas the high antibiotic concentration samples will yield high Cq values, indicating growth inhibition due to the antibiotics. Subsequent dHRMA will verify the identity of each strain. The inventors will also vary the initial sample concentrations for each bacterial strain and confirm that our MD.sup.2A chip and assay will indeed quantify the correct input concentration. Finally, to demonstrate that MD.sup.2A chip has the capacity to detect polymicrobial infections, the inventors will mix two strains and perform the assay.
Chip Assembly
[0070]
Chip System
[0071]
[0072] All references, including publications, patent applications, and patents, cited herein are hereby incorporated by reference to the same extent as if each reference were individually and specifically indicated to be incorporated by reference and were set forth in its entirety herein.
[0073] The use of the terms a and an and the and similar referents in the context of describing the invention (especially in the context of the following claims) are to be construed to cover both the singular and the plural, unless otherwise indicated herein or clearly contradicted by context. The terms comprising, having, including, and containing are to be construed as open-ended terms (i.e., meaning including, but not limited to,) unless otherwise noted. Recitation of ranges of values herein are merely intended to serve as a shorthand method of referring individually to each separate value falling within the range, unless otherwise indicated herein, and each separate value is incorporated into the specification as if it were individually recited herein. All methods described herein can be performed in any suitable order unless otherwise indicated herein or otherwise clearly contradicted by context. The use of any and all examples, or exemplary language (e.g., such as) provided herein, is intended merely to better illuminate the invention and does not pose a limitation on the scope of the invention unless otherwise claimed. No language in the specification should be construed as indicating any non-claimed element as essential to the practice of the invention.
[0074] Preferred embodiments of this invention are described herein, including the best mode known to the inventors for carrying out the invention. Variations of those preferred embodiments may become apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art upon reading the foregoing description. The inventors expect skilled artisans to employ such variations as appropriate, and the inventors intend for the invention to be practiced otherwise than as specifically described herein. Accordingly, this invention includes all modifications and equivalents of the subject matter recited in the claims appended hereto as permitted by applicable law. Moreover, any combination of the above-described elements in all possible variations thereof is encompassed by the invention unless otherwise indicated herein or otherwise clearly contradicted by context.