FRAGMENTATION OF CHAINS OF NUCLEIC ACIDS
20190390250 ยท 2019-12-26
Inventors
Cpc classification
B01L3/502792
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
C12Q2523/303
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C12Q1/6806
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
B01L3/5027
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
G01N29/022
PHYSICS
C12Q2523/303
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
C12Q1/6806
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
B01L2400/0436
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
C12Q1/6806
CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
Abstract
Disclosed are methods and devices for fragmenting chains of nucleic acids (such as DNA) in a liquid sample. A liquid sample is provided, comprising chains of nucleic acids. A sample treatment device has a sample treatment zone. The liquid sample is contacted with the sample treatment zone. Surface acoustic waves (SAWs) are propagated along a surface of the sample treatment zone, or more generated acoustic waves are propagated to couple with the sample, and/or the sample is subjected to freeze-thaw cycling, in order to cause fragmentation of said chains of nucleic acids in the sample.
Claims
1. A method of fragmenting chains of nucleic acids in a liquid sample, the method comprising: providing a liquid sample comprising chains of nucleic acids; providing a sample treatment device, the sample treatment device having a sample treatment zone; contacting said sample with said sample treatment zone; generating and propagating surface acoustic waves (SAWs) along a surface of the sample treatment zone, said SAWs coupling into the sample to cause fragmentation of said chains of nucleic acids in the sample.
2. The method according to claim 1 wherein the liquid sample has volume V, an area of an interface between the sample and the sample treatment zone being area A, wherein the ratio A/V is at least 1000 m.sup.2/m.sup.3.
3. The method according to claim 1 or wherein the sample treatment zone includes an area having roughness Rz at least 10 m.
4. The method according to claim 1 wherein the sample treatment zone includes an array of cavities, being ordered or non-ordered, the cavities cumulatively containing at least part of the sample, optionally all of the sample.
5. The method according to claim 1 wherein the sample treatment zone includes an array of pillars, being ordered or non-ordered.
6. The method according to claim 1 wherein the contact angle between the sample and the sample treatment zone is lower than between the sample and a remaining part of the SAW transmission surface, in order to locate the sample.
7. The method according to claim 1 wherein the sample has a volume of not more than 30 L.
8. The method according to claim 1 wherein the concentration of the chains of nucleic acids in the sample is in the range 5-100 ng/L.
9. The method according to claim 1 wherein the SAW transmission surface is a surface of a superstrate coupled to the SAW transducer.
10. The method according to claim 1 wherein the temperature of the sample is controlled so as not to exceed 37 C.
11. The method according to claim 1 wherein the sample is subjected to active cooling.
12. The method according to claim 1 wherein the sample is frozen, or partially frozen, before the start of coupling SAWs into the sample.
13. The method according to claim 1 wherein, when the sample treatment zone is considered as the first sample treatment zone, the device includes an opposing member providing a second sample treatment zone, adapted to be located in contact with the sample opposite the first sample treatment zone, so that the sample is sandwiched between the first and second sample treatment zones, the opposing member being operable to be reciprocated relative to the SAW transmission surface.
14. The method according to claim 13 wherein, when the SAW transducer is considered as the first SAW transducer and the SAW transmission surface is considered as the first SAW transmission surface, the opposing member provides a second SAW transducer adapted to generate and propagate SAWs along a second SAW transmission surface including the second sample treatment zone, for coupling said SAWs into the sample to cause fragmentation of said chains of nucleic acids in the sample.
15. (canceled)
16. A sample treatment device for fragmenting chains of nucleic acids in a liquid sample, the device comprising: a surface acoustic wave (SAW) transmission surface having a sample treatment zone; a SAW transducer adapted to generate and propagate SAWs along the SAW transmission surface including the sample treatment zone, for coupling said SAWs into the sample to cause fragmentation of said chains of nucleic acids in the sample; wherein the device includes an active cooling means in thermal contact with the sample treatment zone.
17. A sample treatment device for fragmenting chains of nucleic acids in a liquid sample, the device comprising: a surface acoustic wave (SAW) transmission surface having a sample treatment zone; a SAW transducer adapted to generate and propagate SAWs along the SAW transmission surface including the sample treatment zone, for coupling said SAWs into the sample to cause fragmentation of said chains of nucleic acids in the sample; wherein when the sample treatment zone is considered as the first sample treatment zone, the device includes an opposing member providing a second sample treatment zone, adapted to be located in contact with the sample opposite the first sample treatment zone, so that the sample is sandwiched between the first and second sample treatment zones, the opposing member being operable to be reciprocated relative to the SAW transmission surface.
18. The sample treatment device according to claim 17 wherein, when the SAW transducer is considered as the first SAW transducer and the SAW transmission surface is considered as the first SAW transmission surface, the opposing member provides a second SAW transducer adapted to generate and propagate SAWs along a second SAW transmission surface including the second sample treatment zone, for coupling said SAWs into the sample to cause fragmentation of said chains of nucleic acids in the sample.
19. The sample treatment device according to claim 16 wherein one or more phononic structures are provided in order to affect the SAW distribution at the sample treatment zone.
20-78. (canceled)
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0170] Embodiments of the invention will now be described by way of example with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:
[0171]
[0172]
[0173]
[0174]
[0175]
[0176]
[0177]
[0178]
[0179]
[0180]
[0181]
[0182]
[0183]
[0184]
[0185]
[0186]
[0187]
[0188]
[0189]
[0190]
[0191]
[0192]
[0193]
[0194]
[0195]
[0196]
[0197]
[0198]
[0199]
[0200]
[0201]
[0202]
[0203]
[0204]
[0205]
[0206]
[0207]
[0208]
[0209]
[0210]
[0211]
[0212]
[0213]
[0214]
[0215]
[0216]
[0217]
[0218]
[0219]
[0220]
[0221]
[0222]
[0223]
[0224]
[0225]
[0226]
[0227]
[0228]
[0229]
[0230]
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS, AND FURTHER OPTIONAL FEATURES OF THE INVENTION
[0231] In the preferred embodiments of the present invention, DNA such as genomic DNA is subject to treatment using SAWs in order to generate DNA fragments of length particularly suitable for automated sequencing. The use of SAWs allows the use of lower sample volumes and lower powers. The typical size and configuration of SAW transducers also enables the integration of fragmentation into sequencing instrumentation. This enables the implementation of sample preparation pre-sequencing steps within the next generation of sequencing instruments. This allows sequencing to be carried out in one integrated instrument, rather than having a stand-alone fragmenting instrument and a stand-alone sequencer, with a skilled operator required to transfer the DNA fragment sample to the sequencer (as is currently the case). This results in reducing total costs for sequencing, increased automation leading to increased throughput, and a broader uptake of the technique across existing and new sectors. The disclosed approach to DNA fragmentation also enables field-based DNA sequencingas may be required for determining microbial resistance and informing the treatment of infectious disease in the face of the emergence of drug resistance (as seen in rare variants of HIV not identified by traditional genotyping techniques.
[0232] As will be discussed, the approaches disclosed herein allow the use of a planar geometry, which is of particular interest for the development of a cartridge-based approach to fragmentation. The cartridge can be formed, in part, using the transducer, but more preferably, the cartridge may provide the superstrate used in preferred embodiments of the invention, for coupling with a transducer which forms part of a fragmentation apparatus. In this case, it is preferred that the cartridge is disposable.
[0233] In the preferred embodiments of the invention, a liquid sample is placed onto a treatment zone of a SAW transmission surface. The SAW transmission surface supports SAWs in the form of harmonic surface displacements with a frequency of at least 100 kHz, preferably about 1 MHz, and at most 1 GHz or at most 100 MHz. In the most preferred embodiments, the SAW frequency used is in the range 4-10 MHz. SAWs such as Rayleigh waves exist on a solid half space and they exhibit the property of no dispersion. However, other SAWs such as Lamb type waves can be used. Lamb waves are dispersive and this property can be exploited to enhance the amplitude of the surface displacements. The transversal component of these vibrations couple to the liquid sample and radiate compressional waves into the liquid. Due to the difference between the speed of sound in the solid and that of the sample, the compression waves are radiated at an angle which obeys a Snellius type law of refraction. Where there is a free surface of the sample, the longitudinal pressure waves are trapped in the sample due to the acoustic impedance mismatch between air and the liquid and between the liquid and the SAW transmission surface. This is described in more detail in WO 2011/060369, WO 2012/114076, WO 2012/156755 and PCT/GB2014/052672 (WO 2015/033139), the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference.
[0234] The liquid sample shapes the propagation of the sound energy as the air/water interface is a very good reflector of sound as the acoustic impedance mismatch means that 99.99% of the sound wave gets reflected at the interface. This strong reflection at the air/water interface also creates high pressure waves in the sample. Further to this, because a fluid can change shape in response to acoustic forcing, the pressure wave distribution can vary with time. This variation causes differential flows and enhances the shearing of chains of nucleic acids.
[0235] It is preferred that the liquid sample is cooled in order to suppress loss of material due to nebulization, if the system is an open system. Furthermore, the sample can be frozen prior to fragmentation using surface acoustic waves. A particularly suitable configuration uses a Peltier cooler, in order to maintain the planarity of the system. In the case where the sample includes a two phase system, the rheology of the two phase system may change with temperature, allowing emulsification to occur and/or increasing the miscibility of the two phases, which may be disadvantageous. Therefore, even in a closed system, cooling can still provide a useful additional effect.
[0236] The liquid sample is preferably aqueous. Water can dissolve quantities of gas. This property can be used in order to cause cavitation in the sample due the acoustic strain developed in the liquid. Such acoustic strain can enable the nucleation of bubbles which can then act as cavitation centres. The cavitation centres irradiated by harmonic pressure waves in the medium can be used to further assist in the fragmentation of the chains of nucleic acids. Suitable cavitation centres include surface roughness features. For example, an ordered or non-ordered array of cavities may be produced in the sample treatment zone using deep reactive ion etching, e.g. using the Bosch process. Such an etching process tends to form a scalloped surface to the sidewalls of the cavities, having a nanometre length scale. Such features are suitable nucleation centres. Additionally, the edge/corner where the sidewall meets the base of the cavity provide suitable nucleation centres.
[0237] The liquid sample may be treated in order to dissolve gas into it. The gas may be any suitable gas that dissolves in the liquid and which promotes bubble formation. The liquid may be saturated with the gas, or supersaturated with the gas.
[0238] The devices according to preferred embodiments of the invention use at least one interdigitated transducer (IDT) fabricated on a piezoelectric substrate to generate SAWs such as Rayleigh-Lamb type elastic waves. The SAWs propagate along a SAW transmission surface to a sample treatment zone to couple into the liquid sample. A compressional wave is radiated into the liquid, because the speed of sound in the liquid is slower than at the SAW transmission surface and the compressional wave is refracted at an angle relative to the normal from the SAW transmission surface. The long chain molecules in the sample interact with the compressional waves propagating in the liquid sample and absorb the mechanical energy. This heats the sample. To control the internal heating of the sample, and thus to control unwanted thermal damage to the DNA, an active cooling device with heat sink is used to extract excess heat from the irradiated liquid. Indeed such temperature control can be achieved by using a pulsed mode of operation where high peak powers are used over a short time period and the rest of the duty cycle is used to allow the sample to cool down.
[0239] The acoustic impedance mismatch between air and water is 99.99% implying that almost all the sound wave that impinges on the liquid/air interface is reflected or trapped. This fact allows for energy to be pumped into the liquid and to create pressure at a greater efficiency in the liquid.
[0240] The device may form all or part of a chamber that itself forms part of a cartridge or part of a larger microfluidic device. This is discussed in more detail below.
[0241] A harmonic signal is applied to the transducer, of frequency typically not less than 1 MHz and not greater than 1 GHz. This generates a harmonic surface displacement, this surface displacement will generate accelerations of the order 10.sup.6 ms.sup.2 or higher at the surface of the substrate dependent on the frequency used. Where multiple transducers are used, corresponding signals are applied to the transducers. The magnitude, shape and position of the resultant surface displacements can be controlled by corresponding control of the configuration, frequency, phase and number of transducers.
[0242] Turning now to an explanation of the embodiments shown in the drawings, it is believed that micro flows generated via acoustic streaming in liquid samples containing DNA or other such polymeric or long chain materials are drivers for fragmentation of the long chain material into smaller parts. In the simplest embodiment of the present invention, shown in
[0243] One of the drawbacks to using an open geometry for the fragmentation of chains of nucleic acids is the propensity of the sample to nebulise and with it loss of material from the system. This can be overcome to some extent by cooling the sample liquid prior to and subsequent to irradiation by surface acoustic waves. For this reason, as shown in
[0244] Acoustic streaming is a second order effect caused by the propagation or the presence s of acoustic vibrations interacting with a fluid. The streaming can induce rapid counter propagating flows in the sample fluid which can tear apart the strands of DNA or other long chain structures of interest. Bubbles can be a localised source for acoustic streaming.
[0245] In one approach of an embodiment of the invention, the inventors take advantage of the thermodynamic properties of water where the sample is in a partially frozen state. This allows fragmentation to occur at lower powers than otherwise, and a possible mechanism for this is explained below.
[0246] In a specific example of the embodiment schematically shown in
[0247] In a straightforward modification, the upper surface of the transducer except for the sample treatment zone was treated such that it became hydrophobic. This makes it easier to recover the sample or to process the sample further directly on the device.
[0248] With reference to
[0249] The surface temperatures of the samples were measured with the aid of a Fluke Ti25 IR camera. The results of the fragmentation were analysed using an Agilent Bioanalyser 2100 with the 12 k kit.
[0250] In order to further control the temperature of the liquid sample, the user can pulse the SAW excitation of the liquid sample. By altering the duty cycle, the ratio of time spent on to the time spent off, the average power can be kept low but the peak powers can be allowed to become high without heating of the sample being a problem. However, this requires that the total time to be extended so that the sample sees the required amount of SAW irradiation. For example a duty cycle of 50% on and 50% off will require double the time of a continuously irradiated sample. Typical times used for a continuously irradiated sample were 30 s to 120 s whereas a pulsed 50:50 irradiated sample required at least 60 s to 240 s.
[0251]
[0252] The power and the amount of time for which the sample is subjected to SAWs has some influence on the position and shape of the fragmented material's distribution. At low power, fragmentation is not apparent. Only when a threshold power is achieved is suitable fragmentation observed. To illustrate this, consider
[0253] The liquid can be frozen or super cooled prior irradiation with ultrasonic surface acoustic waves. The liquid can be cooled such that only partial melting of the frozen drop is achieved on its surface, when subjected to the ultrasonic actuation. An hypothesis as to the mechanism linked to this could be drawn from results discussed below on the use of superstrates, in that the partially melted liquid is subjected to a roughened interface with the frozen parts. Under such conditions, low powers such as 2 W can be used to achieve the desired fragmentation of below 1000 bp. In this context, the term liquid sample is to be understood to include samples which are liquid at room temperature but which may be solidified, e.g. by freezing, and which at least partially liquefy during the process of fragmentation.
[0254] Another embodiment of the invention is illustrated in
[0255]
[0256] At different operating frequencies, varying behaviour of the liquid sample can be observed. At lower frequencies, there is significant movement of the drop while at higher operating frequencies the drop can be made to vortex with less translational motion and a similar rate of heating in the liquid sample. This movement can be controlled by modifying the surface chemically by changing the surface chemistry locally or physically by introducing a surface topology which augments the planar surface. The present inventors have used a periodic arrays of pits. In one example a hexagonal array was used with pit diameter 70 m, depth 50 m and centre-to-centre spacing 200 m. In another example a hexagonal array was used with pit diameter 140 m, depth 70 m and centre-to-centre spacing 250 m. The inventors observe that they could have used a random array of such pits or even a mechanically roughened surface formed using abrasive techniques. It is considered that one effect of the surface treatment is that the contact line of the liquid is pinned such that enough power can be applied to fragment the material of interest while having control where the liquid goes. However, the liquid can be allowed to move to the far edge of the superstrate, distal from the electrodes where it will remain throughout the fragmentation process, in effect pinned at the edge.
[0257]
[0258] Another advantage of a roughened surface is that it increases the efficiency of the fragmentation process, achieving a desired distribution peak value less than 1000 bp at relatively low applied powers (12 W instead of >30 W). This has the advantage of controlling the temperature of the fragmentation process to be less than 37 C., preferably less than 20 C., thus avoiding any issues of heat stress for any biological samples. The efficiency is achieved by enabling streaming flows to occur adjacent to or on the pitted surface enabling higher shear to occur than would be present on an otherwise flat planar surface.
[0259]
[0260] In
[0261] As shown in
[0262] The superstrate may comprise one or more phononic structures in order to affect the distribution of SAWs at the sample treatment zone. A SAW phononic structure is a structure designed to influence the propagation or distribution of SAWs. These phononic structures may be provided as an array of scattering sites or as one scattering site. Details of different arrangements of phononic structures are set out in WO 2011/060369, WO 2012/114076, WO 2012/156755 and PCT/GB2014052672.
[0263] Suitable phononic structures can be incorporated in the device in a number of ways. For example, they may be directly attached to the surface of the transducer. They may be constructed using solid material or using a number of gas bubbles in the fluid sample containing biologically relevant polymeric material. The phononic structures may be formed directly onto a superstrate where the phononic structure can be constructed out of solid material or depending on the nature of the superstrate could constructed out of a number of gas bubbles held in place for example by capillary forces due to surface chemistry or surface geometry. The phononic strucures may be formed inside the transducer or superstrate, for example embedded into the superstrate as layers of material with different density and elastic modulus such as an array of fluidic channels.
[0264] A simple embodiment of a phononic structure is a thin layer of metal deposited on the surface of a piezoelectric material. The metal shorts out the electrical component associated with the harmonic mechanical deformation of a traveling wave and this has the effect of slowing down the propagation of the SAW. By slowing down the propagation of the leading edge of a traveling wave there rest of wave bunches up, increasing the amplitude of the displacement in an analogous manner to a tsunami. By using this effect the effectiveness of the fragmentation process can be improved by increasing the surface displacement over a small distance and which may cause faster acoustic streaming flows. These flows can be broken up into adjacent regions from an incoming SAW by simply using narrow strips of metal. Multiple transducers operating independently can be used to cause strong acoustic streaming counter flows within the sample. Further, it is known that the use of metallic patterning of the piezoelectric surface can be used to fabricate other dispersive structures such as lenses, beamsplitters and or prisms.
[0265] Such displacement increases can be achieved in other ways. For example, they can be achieved by the addition of material onto the surface of either a transducing substrate or the surface of a superstrate where the speed of sound of the added material is lower than that of substrate or superstrate. Polymers such as SU8, glass and/or aerogels can be considered. Such changes in phase velocity can be achieved by using the dispersive properties of a plate (superstrate) where the phase velocity is dependent on the frequency thickness product. By making the superstrate thicker the phase velocity of a particular mode of propagation can be made to slow down. Note however that the A0 mode is an exception to this rule. When an A0 mode is excited in the superstrate then if the thickness of the superstrate was gradually increased, the mode would propagate at progressively higher velocities until it reached the Rayleigh limit. Another simple way to increase the surface displacement is to position the sample at an edge of another discontinuity that causes a significant reflection.
[0266] Suitable phononic structures include phononic crystal (PhnC) structures or grating structures such as pits, holes, troughs, strips or pillars. Here holes, pits and troughs are considered as type 1 and pillars and strips as type 2. Such structures are dispersive and their transmission properties are frequency dependent. Suitable structures can be designed based on the behaviour required, such as reflection where no Bloch-Floquet modes exist or transmission where the frequency chosen to drive a transducer will couple to Bloch-Floquet modes that can exist or propagate in the PhC structure.
[0267] Type 1 PhnC structures comprise pits, holes or troughs in the transducer or superstrate for example, or in a layer which comprises part of a multilayer superstrate structure. The pits, holes or troughs can behave as cavities supporting particular modes of vibration on the structure or in a fluid and these can be considered closed cavities. The pressure in the cavity can be higher than that of a surrounding fluid. This can be used to improve the probability that fragmentation will occur. However, if desired the pits, holes or troughs can be arranged so as to create an acoustic cavity to enhance the sound field in a particular area. Thus, the whole phononic crystal array can support (Bloch-Floquet) modes and a cavity can be created from a PhnC and excited with SAW. In this manner, a structure can be designed to operate on different length scales, the holes being excited individually at a high frequency or the whole structure at a lower frequency.
[0268] Type 2 PhnC structures are those composed of pillars or strips positioned on a surface. The frequencies used can be chosen such that transduced waves from the transducer can couple to Bloch-Floquet modes of the PhnC structure where the scattering of mechanical waves combine to form high pressure point within the spaces between the pillars or strips. Again structures or frequencies can be chosen such that no Bloch-Floquet modes exist therefore reflecting the sound energy. The structures can be arranged to create a cavity to enhance the sound pressure field in a particular area.
[0269] There is an intermediate case of the above two where the PhnC structure is embedded into either a transducer or a superstrate. For example arrays of channels may be embedded into the transducer or superstrate. Pillars may be provided in such channels. Therefore, dispersive elements can be engineered to control the shape of the sound field in a similar manner to lenses, beam splitters and prisms.
[0270] One problem with using pillars is the high contact angle to water that the structures present. However, the inventors have shown through experiments that such high contact angles can be overcome by the use of SAWs transmissions on a suitable substrate or superstrate where the sound can couple into the liquid and within a short time the liquid wets the pillars and is subsequently dragged down to the structure via capillary action. The use of ultrasound causes the drop to cast micro-droplets which then change the wetting characteristics of the structure. Once the structure is wetted then the power applied can be increased.
[0271] Further embodiments of the invention are now described with reference to
[0272] In
[0273] In
[0274] In another embodiment (not illustrated), an intervening superstrate can be inserted between the opposing transducers. In this configuration, the intervening superstrate may be narrower or wider than one or both of the opposing transducers.
[0275] In
[0276] In a modification of
[0277] The arrangement in
[0278] In
[0279] As will be clear from the disclosure above, the preferred embodiments of the present invention seek to provide efficient and effective DNA fragmentation at relatively low applied power. Existing literature points towards the fact that micro flows generated via acoustic streaming and/or cavitation in liquid samples containing DNA or other such polymeric or long chain materials are drivers for fragmentation of the long chain material into smaller parts. However, these drivers typically have not been accessible in the case of low ultrasonic radiation powers. The preferred embodiments of the invention enable fragmentation using electrical powers associated with portable hand held devices. This opens up the possibility for the field use of next generation sequencing.
[0280] The embodiments of the invention illustrated in
[0281] Acoustic streaming is a second order effect caused by the propagation or the presence of acoustic vibrations interacting with a fluid. The streaming can induce rapid counter propagating flows in the sample fluid which can tear apart the strands of DNA or other long chain structures of interest. Also such streaming flows can be induced via cavitation where micro bubbles (of dissolved gas for example) oscillate due to the presence of ultrasonic pressure waves.
[0282] Preferred embodiments of the invention take advantage of the thermodynamic properties of water where the sample is in a partially frozen state to allow fragmentation to occur at lower powers than otherwise.
[0283] In one suitable embodiment, the invention uses an interdigitated transducer (IDT) on a piezoelectric material such as LiNbO.sub.3 (or any other suitable material that can produce surface vibrations of the desired amplitude and frequency). The results reported here were obtained using 1 mm thick Y cut black LiNbO.sub.3 with an electrode spacing to provide a working frequency of 4.86 MHz, the transducer having a dimension of 23 mm square. A Peltier cooler was attached to a fan assisted heatsink using heat sink compound with the transducer attached to the Peltier cooler using the same heat sink compound. This enabled the system to operate in normal ambient temperatures. The system is as illustrated in
[0284] In the disclosure above, a drop of liquid sample containing between 25 ng/L to 100 ng/L DNA onto the surface of the IDT a suitable distance away from the electrodes. In order to control the temperature of the sample during irradiation from the surface acoustic waves generated by the IDT a cooling device is used such as a Peltier type device. The Peltier device was operated so that the temperature of the sample did not exceed 37 C. The surface temperatures of the samples were measured with the aid of a Fluke Ti25 IR camera. The results of the fragmentation were analysed using an Agilent Bioanalyser 2100 with the 12 k DNA kit. The effect of providing active cooling was found to be that nebulisation of the sample was reduced, compared with the same conditions except without active cooling.
[0285] A further way to control the temperature of the liquid sample is to pulse the transducer. This has been disclosed also in Yeo et al, Lab Chip. 2014 14(11):1858-65. doi: 10.1039/c4lc00232f. By altering the duty cycle, the ratio of on to off, the average power can be kept low but the peak powers can be allowed to become high without heating of the sample being a problem. However, this requires that the total time to be extended so that the sample sees the same amount of ultrasonic wave irradiation. For example a duty cycle of 50% on and 50% off will require double the time of a continuously irradiated sample. Typical times used for a continuously irradiated sample would be 30 s to 120 s whereas a pulsed 50:50 irradiated sample would require at least 60 s to 240 s. Although not dramatically problematic for sequencing applications, the shorter the time, the higher the throughput of processing, which is one of the major parameters in sequencing applications.
[0286] The power and the amount of time taken for the fragmentation have some influence on the position and shape of the fragmented material's distribution. At low powers, fragmentation is not observed and only when a threshold power is used is fragmentation achieved. As mentioned above,
[0287] The liquid was frozen or super cooled prior irradiation with ultrasonic waves, cooled such that only partial melting of the frozen drop was achieved during the irradiation with ultrasonic waves. Under such conditions, low powers can be used to achieve the desired fragmentation of below 1000 bp. It is not known at this time the mechanism by which fragmentation is occurring at these low temperatures and applied powers, where sample surface temperature is below or around 4 C. and applied power can be less than 1 W.
[0288] Without wishing to be limited by theory, a possible mechanism for low temperature and power DNA fragmentation could be that the partially melted sample subjects the liquid phase to a roughened interface due to the presence of the frozen parts. Additionally or alternatively the frozen parts may be free to move within the liquid phase to mechanically break up the DNA in the presence of a harmonic forcing cause by the transducer. However, the explanation of the phenomenon might be due to thermodynamic considerations related to repeated cycles of crystallization, thawing and recrystallization or even a combination of these effects.
[0289] The article provided at: http://www.mlo-online.com/freeze-thaw-cycles-and-nucleic-acid-stability-whats-safe-for-your-samples.php [accessed 7 Oct. 2016] provides some disclosure on the effect of freeze-thaw cycles on DNA. However, this method is apparently not reliable and does not provide good sizes (there is no relevant data provided). See also: http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/pdf/10.1089/bio.2011.0016 [accessed 7 Oct. 2016]
[0290] The embodiments of the invention illustrated in
[0291] At different operating frequencies, varying behaviour of the liquid sample can be observed. At lower frequencies there is significant movement of the drop (i.e. motion of the drop shape), while at higher operating frequencies the drop can be made to vortex (motion of the liquid inside the drop) with less translational motion and a similar rate of heating in the liquid sample. This movement can be controlled by modifying the surface chemically by changing the surface chemistry locally or physically by introducing a surface topology which augments the planar surface. We have chosen to use a periodic array of pits (about 186 m diameter, 203 m pitch) but we could have used a random array of such pits or even a mechanically roughened surface using abrasive techniques. What is considered to be important is that the liquid's contact line is pinned such that enough power can be applied to fragment the material of interest while having control where the liquid goes. In some embodiments the liquid can be allowed to move to the far edge of the superstrate where it will remain throughout the fragmentation process, in effect pinned at the edge.
[0292] The effect of using a roughened surface at the sample treatment zone is illustrated by comparing
[0293] The use of a roughened surface at the sample treatment zone appears to have the effect of increasing the efficiency of the fragmentation process, achieving a desired distribution peak value less than 1000 bp at relatively low applied powers (12 W instead of >30 W). This has the advantage of permitting control of the temperature of the fragmentation process to be less than 37 C., preferably less than 20 C., thus avoiding serious issues of heat stress for biological samples. The efficiency is achieved by enabling streaming flows to occur adjacent to or on the roughened (e.g. pitted) surface enabling higher shear to occur than would be present on an otherwise flat planar surface.
[0294] The embodiments discussed above use an open system in which the liquid sample presents a free surface. With power budgets in the region of 1 W, it would be advantageous for the sample to be enclosed in a microfluidic structure. It is preferred for example that the sample is located in a sample chamber 40, 50 (see
[0295] In the simplest approach, the sample chamber 40 may hold a single phase, i.e. the sample 12 (see
[0296] Suitable sample chambers 40, 50 were formed as microfluidic structures fabricated from glass and silicon where the glass was 1 mm thick and the silicon was 500 m thick. Two approaches were used. The first approach was one where the microfluidic structure was bonded directly to the surface of the transducer with epoxy (
[0297] In the prior art, it is known to enclose the sample in the chamber where the sample is exposed to high power ultrasonic pressure waves. Part of the insight of the present invention is that where substantial powers are used, there is a need for pulsed irradiation and active cooling such that the temperature of the sample does not exceed 37 C., otherwise the sample will be subjected to temperatures that may denature or damage proteins or DNA.
[0298] It is clear from the work reported here that there is a minimum magnitude of ultrasonic excitation required to fragment DNA. However, we have shown that this can be dramatically reduced by choosing suitable conditions, namely control over temperature, for example to ensure that the maximum temperature experienced by the sample is approximately 4 C. We used a number of frequencies ranging from 7.38 to 9.156 MHz and different modes of operation initially pulsed to ensure peak pressures high enough, then continuously when suitable conditions were found. The concentration of DNA used in this work varied from 7 ng/L to 40 ng/L, results for 12 and 20 ng/L being shown here.
[0299] In
[0300] Note that in the present work no specific advantage was determined by fragmenting directly on the piezoelectric surface compared with fragmenting on a superstrate. However, it is possible that an effect is seen, and this may offer a route to further reducing acoustic powers required to fragment DNA.
[0301] In the embodiments shown in
[0302] We can process a chamber filled with a single phase namely the sample, however, it is not entirely clear that such a system could handle a two phase system found in digital microfluidics platforms. One concern mentioned above is the preponderance for the two phases to mix and generate an emulsion which would be deleterious to the operation of an electro wetting on demand (EWOD) system. Emulsification was readily observed at elevated temperatures (>10 C.) and high peak powers (36 W corresponding to input of 400 mV pkpk) when using pulsed mode of excitation. This was suppressed when the device was suitably cooled allowing input signals of 600 mV pkpk to be used (corresponding to 290 W peak power). The electrographs shown in
[0303]
[0304] As can be seen by comparing
[0305]
[0306] The configuration of
[0307] The embodiments illustrated so far use SAW transducers. However, embodiments of the invention also work satisfactorily with bulk acoustic waves, generated using bulk acoustic wave transducers 60 transmitted via waveguide 62. Suitable configurations for such devices are shown in
[0308] Embodiments of the present invention also work satisfactorily using surface shear waves. This is illustrated using the embodiments shown in
[0309]
[0310] In
[0311]
[0312] Further work has been completed by the inventors to investigate the effects of the shape of the interface between the sample and the sample treatment zone. This work has demonstrated that the use of an engineered structure at the interface can have a positive influence on DNA fragmentation via ultrasonic waves acting on a sample containing the DNA. This is the case even while the liquid temperature is kept many degrees centigrade above freezing.
[0313] In the work reported here, the structures used had varying forms (pit, trough, pillar and strip) and varying edge curvatures, depths and heights. Additionally, the structures were formed of different materials. Some superstrates were completely made out of silicon while others were made out of a patterned layer of SU8 (photresist) on a silicon superstrate.
[0314] All the samples were frozen prior to the application of SAW. This was to ensure that all runs had similar starting conditions.
[0315] In these experiments the applied power was approximately 5 W to 15 W but generally 13 W was used from an input to the amplifier of 190 mV pkpk. At this power it is found that the temperature of the liquid does not rise too quickly and fragmentation sizes sub 17000 bp can be produced reproducibly.
[0316] The LiNbO.sub.3 interdigitated transducer was driven at a frequency of approximately 7.3 MHz and was pasted to a Peltier heater/cooler which in turn was pasted to a heatsink used in conjunction with a 12V fan. Temperature of the liquid samples was measured remotely using a Fluke Ti 25 IR thermal imaging camera. The maximum temperature was 53 C. and the minimum 20 C. although generally the temperature was kept to below 40 C. and above 17 C.
[0317] The silicon superstrates were patterned using optical lithography, this photoresist pattern was then transferred into silicon via a dry etch process. The SU8 structures were fabricated using optical lithography. The freeze thaw device was made using metal lift off on a polymeric surface which could be SU8 on silicon or a piece of plastic such as PMMA. With respect to the topologies of the superstrates, the pits or posts were arranged in either triangular or square lattices.
[0318] A Vectawave 80 W RF amplifier used in conjunction with RF power meter. The range of temperatures that all samples shown reached during the application of SAW, was between 10 C. and 41 C. A number of various structures were used arrays of pits or posts and flat or roughened silicon. The source of the DNA used came from Corriel (NA12878) at a concentration of 38 ng/L or 76 ng/L with 9 L used for all runs.
[0319] The minimum depth of the Si pits was approximately 80 m and maximum was approximately 200 m. The minimum height of the posts was approximately 45 m and the maximum height was approximately 145 m. Smallest feature size was 20 m in diameter and the largest was 1000 m in diameter. All silicon superstrates were fabricated using (100) oriented 500 m thick four inch single side polished wafers. An example of the arrayed pit structures is shown in
[0320] With the embodiment of
[0321]
[0322]
[0323] The experimental set up for the superstrate 86 of
[0324]
[0325] Without wishing to be bound by theory, the inventors speculate that the fragmentation yield from the pillar structures is higher than that from the pit structures perhaps because the pillars have a greater degree of freedom to move or provide a larger interaction area with the sample. Also the open structure of a lattice of pillars may promote streaming flows within the liquid sample more effectively that an array of pits.
[0326] The roughness of the superstrate surface, apart from the engineered surface structures (pits or pillars) did not appear to be critical to the fragmentation of DNA under the conditions used. However, as expected the intensity of the acoustic field (magnitude of the elastic waves) influences fragment sizes produced with higher powers typically producing smaller fragments.
[0327] This dependence on acoustic power is shown in the fragmentation carried out on a flat silicon superstrate 88 (a piece of unprocessed silicon wafer), in the arrangement shown in
[0328] As shown in
[0329] For the superstrate reported in
[0330] It was initially considered by the inventors that that the structures needed to be ordered in order to be of benefit to DNA fragmentation performance. However, a silicon wafer that has been used as a backing wafer for a dry etch process develops an altered texture on the backside of the wafer at its periphery. The measured roughness (gauged by white light profilometry (ContourGT Bruker)) of this area of the wafer was about Rz=19 m.
[0331] Comparison of
[0332] SU8 is a negative photoresist that crosslinks a monomer after exposure and baking prior to development in EC solvent. The permanent crosslinking of the monomers in the resist provide resilient structures that will not completely deform when heated. Some reflow of the resist is expected when undergoing hard bakes (120 C. to 230 C.) as complete cross linkage occurs at 240 C. This ability of the polymeric coating to undergo plastic deformation was used to fabricate smooth micron scale structures.
[0333] Two formulations of SU8 were used (designed 3050 and 3025). These respectively provided layer thickness of about 45 m and 20 m. In order to obtain different sidewall angles the 3050 samples were exposed at 30 s, 120 s, 600 s and 900 s. After development of the optical lithography the various samples were hard baked at 120 C., 180 C. and 230 C. between 3 hrs and 20 hrs.
[0334] Higher temperature or longer times for the hard bake causes either more reflow or smoothing of the surface of the SU8.
[0335]
[0336]
[0337] The structures in
[0338] There were also manufactured arrays of pillars using SU8. Pillars with a diameter of 0.3 mm and pitch of 0.5 mm appeared to be less efficient than similar structures fabricated wholly in silicon.
[0339]
[0340]
[0341]
[0342]
[0343] Thus, some pillar structures (having the same diameter of 0.3 mm and pitch of 0.5 mm) perform better than others, comparing
[0344] It is possible to think of the array of pits as a continuous layer of SU8 on the silicon superstrate whereas an array of pillars can be considered a discontinuous layer of SU8. The mass loading on the silicon superstrate will be lower in the case of a discontinuous coating. This may be an additional reason for the poor performance of the pit structure devices compared to the good performance of the pillars structures.
[0345] SU8 device structures were manufactured that were 1D arrays of troughs or strips. These were formed using similar conditions to the structures shown in
[0346]
[0347]
[0348] However, it is found that if the sidewall is linear and an angle of approximately 60 fragmentation could be achieved at 11 W.
[0349]
[0350] It was found that the strip structures performed much better than their trough structure counterparts. SU8 strip structures 1 mm wide with a pitch of 4 mm appeared to perform the best while strip structures 0.5 mm wide and a pitch of 2.5 mm also gave good results. The SU8 3050 layers were approximately 45 m thick whereas the SU8 3025 layers were approximately 20 m thick. There appeared to be a slight bias towards a smaller step height of the structures with respect to yield of fragments whereas peak fragment size appeared to show the reciprocal relationship where bigger step height produced fragment distributions peaks with lower base pair number.
[0351]
[0352] It was noticed that hard bake temperature and time influenced the performance of the SU8 devices. Devices that underwent a long 230 C. hard bake performed less well with respect to yield of material. This would imply that the degree of cross linking of the resist and hence elastic properties changes may be the cause of the difference.
[0353] In
[0354] In more detail,
[0355] We now explain in general terms how the embodiments of the invention can be integrated into a DNA sequencing process, for implementation for example using a sequencing apparatus.
[0356] There are known to the skilled person various approaches for DNA sequencing.
[0357] At step A, DNA is extracted. This step is dependent upon the nature of the sample, and may require lysis and/or purification.
[0358] At step B, the DNA is fragmented. This is carried out as explained in detail above.
[0359] After fragmentation, usually the fragment ends have overhangs that need to be blunted (using enzymes). This is done at step C.
[0360] At step D, an A is added at the end to provide an anchor for the adapter and prevent concatenation during ligation.
[0361] At step E, adapters (short DNA fragments) are added at the end of the sample DNA fragments to enable their hybridization onto the sequencing surfaces.
[0362] At step F, the adequate constructs are selected using size.
[0363] At step G, because the amount of adequate DNA constructs at this stage can be limited, a PCR amplification step is carried out. This also has the effect of purifying the sample.
[0364] Step H is optional. Here, there is the step of validating, normalising and pooling libraries (concentrations, quality).
[0365] Next, at step I, the pre-processed sample is subjected to the DNA sequencing operation itself.
[0366] One or more of steps C to H may be carried out at the sample treatment device used to carry out step B. Alternatively, the sample may be moved using either robotics (pipetting) or microfluidics (pressure or EWOD (electrowetting on demand), for example).
[0367] There are now described approaches to the fragmentation of DNA using freeze-thaw cycling methods, without necessary applying SAWs or other acoustic waves to the sample. However, it is to be understood that these freeze-thaw methods may be used in combination with the SAW or acoustic wave methods set out above.
[0368] Considering first the background to freeze-thaw treatment of DNA, it is known that multiple freezing and thawing of stored sperm samples will cause degradation of chromosomal DNA [Kopeika et al (2015)]. This is a method that has been used to increase the efficiency of gene modifications in gametes [Ventura et al (2009)]. In most cases however, fragmentation of DNA from freeze-thawing is a negative effect that methods have been designed to avoid. For example, in mass spectrometry, samples are frozen and desorbed from a frozen state (without thawing) to avoid unwanted fragmentation, as disclosed in EP-B-0404934 and U.S. Pat. No. 4,920,264.
[0369] Freeze-thawing has been used in preparing libraries for DNA sequencing, but the control obtained on the size or the efficiencies have not made it a preferred methodology [Makarov and Langmore (1999)]. Indeed the sizes of specific protocols have been characterised and shown to be higher than 10 kb [Shao et al (2012)], too large for efficient library preparation.
[0370] EP-A-1752542 discloses a method of generating non-human transgenic animals, including a freeze thaw step to cause fragmentation. U.S. Pat. No. 4,920,264 discloses a method for preparing samples for mass analysis by desorption from a frozen solution. One of the stated aims of this document is to mitigate or minimize fragmentation, and aims to achieve this by freezing target molecules. U.S. Pat. No. 6,117,634 discloses nucleic acid sequencing and mapping and mentions fragmentation as a by-product of freeze-thawing but does not utilise this. WO 2011/031127 discloses a method of isolating DNA from cells, in which rapid freeze thaw cycles between 65 C. and 70 C. are used.
[0371] Here we provide a platform, preferably based on a structured surface, to enhance the efficiency of the fragmentation of DNA by using temperature cycling, which includes a step below the freezing temperature of water. Note that in some circumstance it would be possible to freeze a sample above the triple point of water by the addition of a suitable additive. See, for example, http://news.mitedu/2016/carbon-nanotubes-water-solid-boiling-1128 [accessed 10 Oct. 2017].
[0372] The freeze-thaw method is illustrated here through the use of different heating mechanisms. The efficiency of the method appears to be linked to the presence of a microstructured surface (with feature size in the range of tens of microns, as described above).
[0373] In the work described below, human genomic DNA obtained from Promega Corporation (G3041) and Coriell NA12878 DNA was used with a concentration of 43 ng/L and 38 ng/L respectively, where each sample had a volume of 6 to 9 L.
[0374] Two superstrates were used: a glass coverslip and structured silicon (consisting of pillars 130 m in diameter, 160 m high with a pitch of 230 m) physically connected to a heat source via a small volume of heatsink compound while some samples were carried out directly on PZT\SU8 composite devices (see below).
[0375] The heaters were also thermally connected to a Peltier cooler rated for 6 A via a small volume of heatsink compound.
[0376] The power applied to the heaters was modulated such that the drop could melt and refreeze during each cycle of the modulated applied power, enabling multiple freeze/thaw cycles. Typically the modulation consisted of a square wave with a frequency between 0.05 Hz to 0.5 Hz.
[0377] In a first approach, an RF heater was used. Lead Zirconate Titanate (PZT) is a ferroelectric ceramic which can be used in the fabrication of piezoelectric transducers. A composite material was formed, comprising Ferroperm Pz26 powder (PZT) added to
[0378] SU8 2050 negative tone photoresist at 30% by volume and mixed thoroughly. The mixture was then applied to interdigitated electrodes [obtained from Epigem UK] by first masking off the interdigitated electrodes with Sellotape, with the excess mixture scraped off using the edge of a glass slide. This is illustrated in
[0379] In the present approach, we do not use the PZT/SU8 composite devices for their piezoelectric properties, but for their roughness and ability to heat up quickly on application of a suitable RF signal via the electrodes. To avoid any doubt, we include a characterisation in
[0380]
[0381]
[0382]
[0383]
[0384] Heating using RF was found to be efficient where only 0.1 W of applied power at 32.5 MHz was enough to obtain a temperature of approximately 77 C. after 5 s.
[0385]
[0386] Note that if the PZT/SU8 composite 108 was not present, no significant heating effect was observed when the RF signal was applied to the electrodes 102.
[0387]
[0388] Based on
[0389] Heating via a resistive heater was also found to be effective. Resistive thermal devices (RTD) were used as micro strip heaters. These devices were produce via a lift off technique, where the device pattern was created lithographically on 300 m thick Pyrex glass followed by evaporating 100 nm of a suitable metal (e.g. Pt or NiCr) to create a serpentine track. The single wire was used as a heating element when a current, as high as 2.6 A, was passed through the device. The current supplied to the heaters was modulated with frequency of 0.05 Hz. The devices were used in conjunction with a superstrate. The superstrate was either a smooth glass coverslip or a structured silicon superstrate. These were coupled to the heater with the aid of heatsink compound.
[0390]
[0391] It can be seen when comparing
[0392] The embodiments of the freeze-thaw approach tested here use open systems. However, further embodiments would adopt features disclosed with the respect to the SAW and acoustic wave embodiments. In particular, it is envisaged to use closed chambers and/or two phase enveloped samples. It is considered that the fragmentation efficiency found using the structured superstrate would follow the same behaviour found with respect to the dimensions and shapes of the structured superstrates investigated in the SAW and acoustic wave embodiments.
[0393] Different approaches can be taken for heating the sample. For example, the sample may be heated (directly or indirectly) by radiation (such as an IR source (e.g. a flame) or IR/terahertz/visible diode or other radiation source, or laser), convection (warm air) or by contact with a heated source.
[0394] It is also possible to include particles in the sample (e.g. magnetic beads or plasmonic particles) that preferentially would heat up upon activation (e.g. via radiation or other excitement). Such an approach may have additional advantages in the sense of providing additional surfaces for fragmentation. Furthermore, such an approach may provide a means for capture of fragments. For example, the beads may be coated with suitable capture molecules or surface. Note that in some embodiments it is preferable not to include such further particles, in view of the desirability of removing such particles before sequencing, which therefore adds an additional processing step.
[0395] While the invention has been described in conjunction with the exemplary embodiments described above, many equivalent modifications and variations will be apparent to those skilled in the art when given this disclosure. Accordingly, the exemplary embodiments of the invention set forth above are considered to be illustrative and not limiting. Various changes to the described embodiments may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
[0396] All references referred to above and/or listed below are hereby incorporated by reference.
LIST OF NON-PATENT REFERENCES
[0397] Marine R. et al., Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 77 (2011), 8071 [0398] Q. Tseng, A Lomonosov, E. Furlonga and C. Merten Fragmentation of DNA in a sub-microliter microfluidic sonication device Lab Chip, 2012, 12, 4677-4682, DOI: 10.1039/C2LC40595D [0399] Y. Okabe and A. Lee LCAT DNA Shearing Journal of Laboratory Automation, 2014, Vol. 19(2) 163-170 [0400] Larguinho M., Santos H. M., Doria G., Scholz H., Baptista P. V., Capelo J. L. Development of a fast and efficient ultrasonic-based strategy for DNA fragmentation Talanta 81 (2010) 881-886 [0401] N. Nama, P. Huang, T. Huang, F. Costanzo Investigation of acoustic streaming patterns around oscillating sharp edges Lab Chip, 2014, 14, 2824 [0402] Wu, T. & Chang, I., 2005. Actuating and detecting of microdroplet using slanted finger interdigital transducers. Journal of Applied Physics, 98(2), 024903-7 [0403] Shao et al BIOPRESERVATION AND BIOBANKING Volume 10, Number 1, 2012, -10.1089/bio.2011.0016 [0404] Hedskog C. et al., PLOS One, 5 e11345 (2010) [0405] R. J. Shilton, S. M. Langelier, J. R. Friend and L. Y. Yeo Surface acoustic wave solid-state rotational micromotor Appl. Phys. Lett. 100, 033503 (2012) http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3676660 [0406] http://www.mlo-online.com/freeze-thaw-cycles-and-nucleic-acid-stability-whats-safe-for-your-samples.php [0407] http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/pdf/10.1089/bio.2011.0016 [0408] Kopeika, J.; Thornhill, A.; Khalaf, Y. The Effect of Cryopreservation on the Genome of Gametes and Embryos: Principles of Cryobiology and Critical Appraisal of the Evidence. Hum. Reprod. Update 2015, 21 (2), 209-227 DOI: 10.1093/humupd/dmu063. [0409] Ventura, O. M.; Gutierrez, A.; Motoliu, J. Method of Generating Non-Human Transgenic Animals. EP1752542 (A1), May 27, 2009. [0410] Hunter, J. M.; Lin, H.; Becker, C. H. Cryogenic Frozen Solution Matrixes for Analysis of DNA by Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry. Anal. Chem. 1997, 69 (17), 3608-3612 DOI: 10.1021/ac9703764. [0411] Makarov, V. L.; Langmore, J. Compositions and Methods for Analysis of Nucleic Acids. WO9839485 (A2), Feb. 25, 1999. [0412] Shao, W.; Khin, S.; Kopp, W. C. Characterization of Effect of Repeated Freeze and Thaw Cycles on Stability of Genomic DNA Using Pulsed Field Gel Electrophoresis. Biopreservation Biobanking 2012, 10 (1), 4-11 DOI: 10.1089/bio.2011.0016.