Electro-physiological measurement with reduced motion artifacts
09603542 ยท 2017-03-28
Assignee
Inventors
- Jeroen Veen (Eindhoven, NL)
- Mohammed Meftah (Eindhoven, NL)
- Nicolaas Lambert (Eindhoven, NL)
- Bart Michiel De Boer (Eindhoven, NL)
- Bastiaan Feddes (Eindhoven, NL)
- Lena Gourmelon (Eindhoven, NL)
- Ronald Rietman (Eindhoven, NL)
- Sri Andari Husen (Eindhoven, NL)
Cpc classification
A61B5/302
HUMAN NECESSITIES
International classification
Abstract
An apparatus and method (4,5,6,7,2) for capacitive measurement of electrophysiological signals (1) suppresses or reduces motion artifacts by providing a feedback mechanism. An average voltage between a capacitive sensor electrode (1) and the body (3) is controlled so as to reduce or minimize motion-induced signals.
Claims
1. An apparatus configured to measure at least one electrophysiological signal of a body, comprising: at least one capacitive sensor electrode; a vibrator configured to vibrate the at least one capacitive sensor electrode, or a support or casing supporting or housing the at least one capacitive sensor electrode, and a feedback loop coupled to the vibrator to generate a feedback signal to control an average voltage between the at least one capacitive sensor electrode and the body for reducing or minimizing the average voltage.
2. The apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the frequency of the vibration is outside of a bioelectric frequency band of the electrophysiological signal to be measured.
3. An apparatus configured to measure at least one electrophysiological signal of a body, comprising: at least one capacitive sensor electrode which generates a sensor output signal which includes an additive mixture of the at least one electrophysiological signal and motion induced signals; a circuit configured to control an average voltage between the at least one capacitive sensor electrode and the body, the circuit including: a processing circuit configured to estimate a power or an entropy of the sensor output signal of the at least one capacitive sensor electrode, a feedback subcircuit configured to generate a feedback signal based on the average voltage, and a control subcircuit configured to bring the average voltage to a defined value; wherein the processing circuit is configured to estimate the average voltage and iteratively adjust the estimated average voltage based on a slope of a change in the estimated power or entropy relative to a change in the average voltage and wherein a convergence speed to the estimated average voltage is slower than an oscillation rate of the electrophysiological signal.
4. An apparatus configured to measure at least one electrophysiological signal V.sub.bio of a body comprising: at least one capacitive sensor electrode which has a measurement capacitance and outputs a measurement signal including the at least one electrophysiological signal V.sub.bio and a motion component; a reference electrode configured to output a reference signal V.sub.ref; a buffer amplifier configured to receive the at least one electrophysiological signal V.sub.bio and output an output voltage V.sub.o; a subtraction circuit configured to subtractively combine the output voltage V.sub.o and the reference signal V.sub.ref; an integrator configured to integrate the subtractively combined output voltage V.sub.o and the reference signal V.sub.ref and derive an equalizing feedback signal V.sub.f; a capacitive network connected between the at least one capacitive sensor and the buffer amplifier; and an equalizing circuit configured to feedback the equalizing feedback signal V.sub.f to the capacitive network for equalizing a transfer function V.sub.o/V.sub.bio to adaptively control the transfer function V.sub.o/V.sub.bio, such that the equalizing feedback signal V.sub.f brings a gain of the buffer amplifier to unity.
5. The apparatus according to claim 4, further comprising: means configured for modulating the reference signal V.sub.ref to a value above a maximum expected frequency of the electrophysiological signal of interest, and means configured for demodulating the subtractively combined output voltage V.sub.o and reference signal V.sub.ref to generate a demodulated subtractively combined output voltage V.sub.o and reference signal V.sub.ref for integration by the integrator to generate the equalizing feedback signal V.sub.f.
6. An apparatus configured to measure at least one electrophysiological signal of a body, comprising: at least one capacitive sensor electrode; at least one reference electrode arranged to be close to or in galvanic contact with the body, wherein the at least one reference electrode is connected to a voltage source, a current source or a reference potential; and a circuit configured to actively control an average voltage between the at least one capacitive sensor electrode and the body by reducing or minimizing an electric field between the at least one capacitive sensor electrode and the body to reduce or minimize motion-induced signals caused by the electric field and variations in a distance between the at least one capacitive sensor electrode and the body, wherein the circuit includes: an oscillator configured to generate an oscillating signal with a higher frequency than a frequency of the electrophysiological signal; a modulator configured to modulate one of a signal from the capacitive sensor or a reference signal indicative of motion induced components with the oscillating signal; an amplifier configured to amplify the electrophysiological signal; a demodulator configured to demodulate the amplified electrophysiological signal with the oscillating signal; and an integrator configured to integrate the demodulated amplified electrophysiological signal to generate a feedback signal to control the average voltage.
7. The apparatus according to claim 6, wherein the at least one sensor electrode includes at least two sensor electrodes coupled to inputs of a differential amplifier.
8. The apparatus according to claim 6, wherein the at least one sensor electrode includes at least two sensor electrodes configured to measure essentially the same electrophysiological signal and adapted to be arranged at different distances to the body and/or supplied with different average voltages, a feedback signal being generated based on output signals of the sensor electrodes so as to bring the average voltage to a defined value.
9. The apparatus according to claim 8, wherein the at least one sensor electrode includes at least three sensor electrodes, the at least three sensor electrodes being arranged: in a triangular fashion, or in concentric circles, or in the form of small segments, the segments of all electrodes being distributed in an interspersed manner, or in segments arranged as a ring or a matrix.
10. The apparatus according to claim 6, further including at least one buffer amplifier configured to convert an output signal of the at least one capacitive sensor electrode, applied to an input of the buffer amplifier, into an output signal while keeping the average voltage on the at least one capacitive sensor electrode at a level defined by a signal applied to a further input of the buffer amplifier.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
(1) These and other aspects of the invention will be apparent from and elucidated with reference to the embodiments described hereinafter. In the following drawings:
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
(20) Generally, contactless (capacitive) measurement of electrophysiological signals is able to overcome disadvantages of skin irritation during prolonged usage, restriction of the patient from free moving and providing less comfort for the patient, i.e. the patient is aware of being monitored.
(21) In the technique according to one or more embodiments described in the following, a capacitor is effectively formed in which the human tissue acts as one of the capacitor plates and the plate electrode of the sensor acts as the other capacitor plate. In the capacitive sensing, no galvanic contact to the skin is needed (i.e. contactless sensing), thereby not needing skin preparation and a sticky patch with conductive gel for establishing a good electrical contact. It is apparently advantageous, in particular, when a lengthy measurement has to be conducted.
(22)
(23) In the diagram of
(24)
applies where
(25) V.sub.dc is the average potential difference between the capacitor electrodes 1, 3,
(26) V.sub.ac is the motion-induced voltage variation detected by the buffer amplifier 2,
(27) d.sub.dc is the average distance between the capacitor electrodes 1, 3,
(28) d.sub.ac is the motion-induced time distance variation between the capacitor electrodes 1, 3.
(29) For a more complex geometry the behavior is slightly modified but essentially the same.
(30) The actually measured ac signal V.sub.measured on the electrode 1 is an addition of the motion-induced signal V.sub.ac and the desired bio signal V.sub.bio on the skin 3. It is not easy to separate these signals without further information on desired signal or motion:
V.sub.measured=V.sub.ac+V.sub.bio.(2)
(31) Basically, in an electric field between two parallel capacitor plates at different potentials, motion-induced distance variation between the plates causes unwanted signals proportional to the electric field and the distance variation.
(32) When the two parallel capacitor plates are held at equal average potential, the electric field (due to external sources) is now mostly external of the plates. The sense electrode can be shielded from these external influences by proper shielding or active guarding. Evidently, external electric fields, e.g. from the mains, can be shielded by well-known proper shielding techniques like grounded shielding and active guards. But the electric field between skin 3 and electrode 1 is an essential part of the desired signal coupling and cannot be shielded. In accordance with one or more of the embodiments, the electric field is controlled, for example by controlling the average voltage between electrode and skin and/or by avoiding any insulating materials or electrically floating conductors that could introduce uncontrollable charges in the space where motion occurs.
(33) Electro-potential differences between skin and electrode may also stem from material differences between the two surfaces. These potential differences are related to the work function differences in vacuum, to galvanic cell potentials in an electrolyte environment, and to the tribo-electric series for rubbed electrodes in air. The potential differences depend on the material and surface conditions and are typically in the order of a volt for the work function and electrolyte potentials. For surfaces in air very similar potential differences exist and they can vary by several tenths of a volt with temperature, humidity, contamination, oxidation. In the case of the human skin the surface potential also depends on many physiological aspects, e.g. sodium- and potassium-ion densities in the skin depend on hydratation and stretching. Therefore, even when body and sense electrode are at the same galvanic potential, a significant electric field between skin and electrode can still be present which, combined with distance electrode-to-body variation, will cause motion-induced signals.
(34) In accordance with one or more of the embodiments a mechanism or features are provided that control the average voltage between body and electrode such that it minimizes the induced motion signal. The methods and devices according to embodiments described below effectively minimize the electric field between body and electrode and thus remove a root cause of the motion artifacts.
(35) To control the average voltage between body 3 and electrode 1, a reference electrode 4 is provided that is in galvanic contact with the body 3. The control can be achieved in various ways, see for example the circuit diagrams of
(36)
(37)
(38) In
(39) When the input impedance of the buffer amplifier 2 and the parallel resistor 7 are extremely high, for example more than 10 Gigaohm or more than 50 Gigaohm, the current source solution of e.g.
(40) In other embodiments any technique can be used that is able to measure the induced motion signal for controlling the voltage between the body 3 and sense electrode 1 in a minimizing feedback mechanism. Some examples are as follows. When the motion is not known, post-processing filtering techniques can be applied to the sense electrode signal such that (all or a part of) the natural motion-induced signal (that is for example outside the frequency band of the desired signal) is separated from the sense electrode signal and this separated signal is used for feedback in a minimizing scheme. This may involve some stepwise or modulated feedback signal to find out the proper direction towards minimization. This is further explained in a below described embodiment.
(41) When the motion is known by other means, e.g. from an actuator-induced known motion system, or from a separate motion sensor like an accelerometer or an optical sensor or so, this known motion can be correlated/multiplied with the signal from the sense electrode 1 to obtain a proper feedback signal. Because the average correlation/multiplication result is signed it can be used directly as a feedback signal without the need of additional modulation. Examples are provided in below described embodiments.
(42) The feedback circuit itself can act on the measurement electrode 1 or on the body reference electrode 4, and the circuit ground 6 can be chosen at the body reference potential or close to the electrode potential or somewhere else.
(43) In these or other embodiments the average voltage between body 3 and electrode 1 is controlled.
(44) The feedback loop can be relatively slow because the average voltage between body and electrode for which the motion artifacts are minimized varies only slowly due to temperature drift and electro-chemical surface changes. For the optimal average voltage between body and electrode the motion-induced signals are minimized for a wide range of frequencies. Also note that the feedback loop can automatically compensate for various other slowly varying offsets in the system.
(45) In order to control the average voltage between body and electrode, a galvanic connection between the feedback system and both body and electrode is needed. But because the feedback is relatively slow and only leakage currents have to be overcome, the requirements on that galvanic connection are very mild. For example even a reference electrode 4 that touches the body 3 only indirectly through a slightly conductive medium is sufficient. An extreme but practical case is a relatively large electrode 4 that has a clear capacitive link to the body 3 and only a very poorly conductive contact, e.g. through a layer of textile. The poorly conductive contact is enough for the relatively slow feedback and for avoiding clipping. The capacitive part of the reference electrode 4 can now induce motion artifacts in the same manner as described above. But if multiple capacitive sensors are connected to that same reference electrode and we only measure voltage differences between those multiple capacitive sensors, the motion-induced signal of the reference electrode 4 is a common mode signal. That common mode signal is easily removed by a differential or instrumentation amplifier when the influence of further parasitics in the capacitive sensors is properly avoided.
(46)
(47) Because one or more embodiments of the invention use a relatively slow feedback they can be combined with many other techniques that attempt to improve signal quality and remove artifacts. E.g. standard motion artifacts filtering techniques can be combined with embodiments of the invention because they work in different ways.
(48) Embodiments of the method may be implemented so that any motion-induced variation in transfer function of the desired electro-physiological signals is, or is not, compensated for. E.g. a neutralization can be used to reduce these types of motion artifacts and can be combined with embodiments of the invention.
(49) An advantage of the above or below described embodiments or more generally an electric circuit added to the biological signal amplifier(s), for reducing common-mode interference, such as a driven-right-leg system, is that unwanted common mode signals between two or more measurement electrodes such as electrodes 1, 12 may be reduced. Practical implementations may typically also set the average voltage between body 3 and electrodes. The advantages of such a driven-right-leg system and of the described embodiments can be easily combined because the feedback of one or more embodiments according to the invention may be relatively slow while the unwanted common mode signals are at much higher frequencies like the 50 Hz or 60 Hz power grid frequency.
(50) In the following, embodiments of a capacitive sensor with reduced motion artifacts using multiple co-located electrodes will be described.
(51) As mentioned above, capacitive sensors for electro-physiological measurements may suffer from motion artifacts due to varying distance between the capacitive electrode(s) and the body. These artifacts may to a large extent be due to the presence of an average electric field between skin and electrode. In accordance with one or more of the embodiments described below or above, it is proposed to combine measured signals from multiple co-located electrodes to control the average voltage between capacitive electrode and body such that the motion-induced signals are reduced or minimized.
(52) By combining signals from multiple co-located electrodes information can be gained on the motion-induced signals. Two, three or more electrodes may be used. A particular choice of a three-electrode solution is described in more detail below. The embodiments provide some details on the associated measurement circuits and electrodes.
(53) In the embodiments described below, circuit elements are provided that comply with requirements of extremely low input capacitance, extremely high input impedance, low offset, and control over average electrode voltage. Further, an example of an analog circuit for suitable signal combination is provided.
(54) In addition some electrode geometries are shown that are able to meet symmetry requirements in accordance with one or more of the embodiments.
(55) As mentioned above, in the basic circuit diagram of a capacitive sensor electrode 1 with buffer amplifier 2 shown in
(56)
applies.
(57) The quantities V.sub.dc, d.sub.dc and d.sub.ac that underlie the motion-induced signal V.sub.ac are essentially unknown in a practical situation.
(58) The actually measured ac signal V.sub.measured on the electrode is an addition of the motion-induced signal V.sub.ac and the desired bio signal V.sub.bio on the skin that is not easily separated without further information on desired signal or motion:
V.sub.measured=V.sub.ac+V.sub.bio.(4)
(59) When combining, in accordance with one or more of the embodiments, multiple electrodes that measure the potential of the skin at essentially the same location so they share essentially the same V.sub.bio, but at different average voltages and/or different average distance, information about the motion can be obtained and a suitable feedback signal may be provided for obtaining a signal with reduced motion artifacts.
(60) In accordance with one or more of the embodiments a three electrode solution is provided. This variant of the above concept will be discussed in more detail. Three co-located electrodes a, b and c are used which sense essentially the same (unknown) bio signal V.sub.bio and undergo essentially the same (unknown) motion d.sub.ac. Electrode a is at (unknown) average distance d, and (unknown) average voltage V. Electrode b is at average distance d+d and at average voltage V+V, and electrode c is also at average distance d+d but at average voltage VV. The static geometric parameter d and the static voltage difference V are known. Applying the equations for induced motion signals we arrive at the following measured signals on the three electrodes:
V.sub.a=V.sub.bio+Vd.sub.ac/d(5)
V.sub.b=V.sub.bio+(V+V)d.sub.ac/(d+d)(6)
V.sub.c=V.sub.bio+(VV)d.sub.ac/(d+d).(7)
(61) By combining these measured signals the unknown V.sub.bio and d.sub.ac can be eliminated and a useful relation between the unknown V and d can be set up, e.g.
V=d(V/d)(V.sub.b+V.sub.c2V.sub.a)/(V.sub.bV.sub.c).(8)
(62) The distance d between electrode a and skin is not known, but obviously it has to be positive.
(63) Therefore the signal combination
(V.sub.b+V.sub.c2V.sub.a)/(V.sub.bV.sub.c)(9)
is proportional to the unknown V, and even though the proportionality factor is unknown, the sign of the proportionality factor is known. So this expression can be used in a feedback scheme to drive the unknown V towards zero. This essentially makes the electric field for electrode a zero, which in turn makes the measured signal on electrode equal to V.sub.bio hence motion-artifact free. Other functions of the measured signals are also possible.
(64) To illuminate the relation between the three signals further we first consider the situation where the circuits are perfectly balanced around optimum average voltage V=0. In this case the measured signal V.sub.a on electrode a represents the desired bio signal V.sub.bio directly, and the measured signals V.sub.b and V.sub.c on electrodes b and c deviate symmetrically around it by a voltage difference of +/V d.sub.ac/(d+d). In other words the voltage differences V.sub.bV.sub.a and V.sub.aV.sub.c are equal. If now the average voltage on all three electrodes rises such that V>0, the voltage difference between electrode b and a becomes
V.sub.bV.sub.a=d.sub.ac(dVVd)/d(d+d)(10)
while the voltage difference between electrode a and c becomes
V.sub.aV.sub.c=d.sub.ac(dV+Vd)/d(d+d).(11)
(65) Clearly, the signals on electrodes b and c are no longer symmetric around electrode a and this effect can be exploited to generate a feedback signal that drives the unknown average voltage V to zero.
(66) Apart from the function mentioned above, there are many other possibilities for feedback. E.g. when d>0 and V>0, the following function can be used:
exp(V.sub.bV.sub.a)exp(V.sub.aV.sub.c)=exp(d.sub.acV/(d+d))sin h(d.sub.acVd/d(d+d)).
(67) If treating the expression as a function of the quickly varying motion d.sub.ac, we see that the sin h ( ) function in the expression is anti-symmetric around zero and has a slope proportional to V, while the exponential function is always positive with a positive slope. So the average of this function is a non-zero value with sign opposite to the unknown V that can be used to drive the system towards the desired situation with V=0. Many other non-linear functions like log(V.sub.bV.sub.a)log(V.sub.aV.sub.c) or (V.sub.bV.sub.a).sup.2(V.sub.aV.sub.c).sup.2 lead to similar results.
(68) Usually, there is non-zero (but unknown) motion d.sub.ac. When there is no motion no motion artifacts occur. The proposed three electrode solution provides sufficient symmetry between the three electrodes and measurements: offset and gain of the three measurements systems is sufficiently equal, the effect of parasitics on the measurements low, and the variables V, V, V.sub.bio, d, d and d.sub.ac as defined above have sufficiently equal values for all three electrodes. This can all be achieved by proper electronic and geometric design. Some of the electronic aspects and geometrical aspects of the design are discussed below. Variations of the three electrode solution described above are possible. Adding more electrodes can provide more information and more accurate feedback.
(69) An embodiment using only two electrodes can be used to improve other mechanisms that provide feedback for optimising the average voltage for minimum motion artifacts. Two co-located electrodes that are at the same distance but at different average voltage combined with a separate motion estimating mechanism can be used to drive the average voltage in the right direction towards the optimum. Two co-located electrodes that are at the same average voltage but at different distance can help separating the motion artefact signal from the bio signal.
(70) Some schematics will be described below. For each sense electrode a circuit 20 (
(71) A basic implementation of this functionality using a standard ultra-high input impedance operational amplifier 24 is shown in
(72) This circuit of
(73)
(74) The time-constant R2*C1 (components 29, 28) drives the slow integration of the offset compensation, resistor 30, R3, provides a means to improve phase stability at higher frequencies, and the ratio of the sum of resistors to the resistor 31 (R5+R4)/R4 serves as a multiplying factor for the effective input impedance of the circuit.
(75) In practice these circuit can have a significant input capacitance which together with varying skin-electrode capacitance due to motion may create undesirable motion artifacts in signal transfer function of the circuit. As already mentioned above this can be reduced by known active guarding and neutralisation circuits.
(76)
(77)
(78) The filter block 43 and the three buffer amplifiers 20 can be implemented in many ways, including digital circuits.
(79)
(80) Regarding the embodiments using co-located electrodes as described above and below, optional features of the suggested approach is that the electrodes 40 to 42 measure essentially the same bio signal V.sub.bio, share essentially the same electro-potential difference V between skin surface and electrode surface, share essentially the same motion d.sub.ac, and that electrodes b and c are at essentially the same common distance from the skin. A first measure to take is to put the electrodes 40 to 42 closely together and provide a suitable mechanical attachment for positioning them at the skin surface, see e.g.
(81)
(82) To be less sensitive to skin curvature, electrode tilt and signal gradients along the skin surface, it may be beneficial to use a more symmetric electrode assembly, see e.g.
(83) In the embodiment of
(84) For proper performance of the electronic circuitry a certain minimum electro surface area is required. To make the co-location of the electrodes even better it is possible to split up the area into multiple smaller electrode segments, see a
(85) Obviously more geometries are possible with similar advantages. For other solutions with a different number of co-located electrodes than three, similar reasoning leads to slightly different electrode patterns.
(86) Note that the inter-electrode capacitance can be significant and tends to grow when using multiple electrode segments. For avoiding or reducing such an effect, the electrodes can be shielded from each other using a suitable active guarding scheme (not shown here). External fields may also be properly guarded such that the electrodes are only exposed to the intended skin area.
(87) In accordance with one or more of the embodiments according to the invention, which may be implemented alone or may be freely combined with one or more of the above described embodiments, a motion artifacts reduction in capacitive bioelectric sensing is achieved using a vibrating probe.
(88) As mentioned above, the combination of skin-electrode distance variation and the presence of an offset voltage (i.e. electric field) across the skin-electrode capacitive coupling, e.g. due to electro-chemical potential differences and amplifier bias offset, may cause artifacts in electrophysiological measurements. In the embodiments according to the invention, described below, a method and device are proposed that significantly reduce the artifacts by compensating the offset voltage using a vibrating capacitive probe in combination with a feedback mechanism.
(89) In the embodiments described above, the motion induced signals may be proportional to both the electric field between electrode and skin and to the motion components along that electric field. As mentioned above, the average voltage between the body and electrode may be actively controlled such that the electric field between body and electrode and thus the motion-induced signal are minimized. To control the average voltage between body and electrode, a reference electrode is provided. Since only small and slowly time-varying voltages have to be controlled, the requirements on that galvanic connection are very mild. For example even a reference electrode that touches the body only indirectly through a slightly conductive medium is sufficient. The control can be achieved in various ways, see the circuit diagrams in the attached illustrating
(90) As mentioned above, the combination of skin-electrode distance variation and the presence of an offset voltage (i.e. electric field) across the skin-electrode capacitive coupling, e.g. due to electro-chemical potential differences and amplifier bias offset, may cause artifacts in electrophysiological measurements. A detailed description of the problem will be given by means of
(91) In this embodiment we assume that the input capacitance C.sub.i is eliminated using a known neutralization technique. In
(92)
(93) In the embodiments according to
(94) The motion artifact signal S(t) equals the offset voltage DC times the natural motion signal N(t)
S(t)=DC.Math.N(t).(12)
(95) By neutralizing the offset voltage, i.e. forcing DC=0, the motion artifacts will be minimized. The method and device described here in order to archive this goal are as follows.
(96) Adding a reference vibration R(t) to the capacitive probe, e.g. a sensor electrode such as electrode 1, 12, results in a motion artifact signal of
S(t)=DC.Math.(N(t)+R(t))(13)
which is applied to the input of unity gain amplifier 60.
(97) Multiplying, in multiplier 63, equation (18) with the reference vibration R(t) applied via line 62 gives
(98)
(99) Preferably R(t) is sinusoid described as R(t)=r cos(.sub.Rt), such that
M(t)=DC.Math.N(t).Math.R(t)+DC.Math.r.sup.2DC.Math.r.sup.2 cos(2.sub.Rt).(15)
(100) The frequency of the vibration .sub.R generated by oscillator 56 is preferably outside the bioelectric frequency band. Integration of equation (20) averages out the AC part of M(t). Next, the output signal of the integrator such as integrator 64, which represents the deviation of DC from zero, is fed back 65 to the body via the reference electrode, e.g. electrode 4 or 11, and effectively subtracted from DC, as shown by adder 58. Alternatively, the output of integrator 64 can be fed back to the sense electrode 1, 12 etc. After convergence of the loop, this results in neutralization of the offset voltage (DC=0) and therefore in a reduction/elimination of the motion artifacts.
(101) According to
(102) Embodiments according to this aspect are not limited to the use of an integrator as described above. Other, more intelligent, filters/controllers are possible, e.g. non-linear controllers or filters with an adaptive bandwidth that combine fast loop convergence and accuracy.
(103) Embodiments according to this and the other aspects of the invention provide a bioelectric signal free from motion artifacts by the use of a vibrating probe.
(104) The statistical independence of the motion-induced signal from the electrophysiological signal can be increased artificially by mechanically mounting the sensor to its housing via an elastic object, such as a spring or cantilever. When excited by an external motion, the resulting mass-spring system oscillates primarily at its natural frequency. As a consequence, a motion-induced signal in the sensor signal will occur in a frequency range that is known a priori, and although the excitation of the vibration may be correlated with the electrophysiological signal, the oscillation is not.
(105) In embodiments, the vibration of the capacitive sensor according to a predefined reference can be performed in different ways.
(106)
(107)
(108)
(109) In
(110) The following techniques can for example be used to produce a vibration: electret based motion induction, electromagnetic motion, piezo (including stacked actuator designs and bimorph designs, thermal expansion based motion induction, air pressure and electro-active polymers. In case the vibrating elements cannot produce large desired motion it is possible to use a smart lever system that converts small vibration into large ones. Also operating the vibrating element in resonance can be beneficial, e.g. to reduce energy consumption.
(111) In the following, embodiments will be described which comprise a capacitive sensor with motion artifact reduction using adaptive mixture minimization. These embodiments can be used as individual solutions and can optionally also be combined with parts or all of other embodiments described or shown above or below.
(112) As mentioned above, motion artifacts in capacitive sensors can be reduced by controlling the average electrode-body voltage. The following embodiments propose to extract an indicator of said voltage, directly from the sense electrode signal, and use that indicator to control a compensation signal. The control system can operate at a relatively slow pace, since the average voltage varies only slowly in time, due to e.g. temperature drift and electro-chemical surface changes. The proposed post-processing methods in accordance with one or more of the embodiments exploit the statistical independence of the motion-induced signals and the electrophysiological signal of interest. Since the mixture is partly additive, in an embodiment the indicator used equals the average sensor signal power and the compensation signal is controlled such that the average power is minimized.
(113) As mentioned above, motion induced signals are proportional to both the electric field between electrode and skin and to the motion components along that electric field. Based on this insight it is proposed above to actively control the average voltage between the body and electrode such that the electric field between body and electrode and thus the motion-induced signal are minimized. To control the average voltage between body and electrode, a reference electrode is provided. Since only small and slowly time-varying voltages have to be controlled, the requirements on that galvanic connection are very mild. For example even a reference electrode that touches the body only indirectly through a slightly conductive medium is sufficient. The control can be achieved in various ways, see for some examples the circuit diagrams of
(114) In the following embodiments it is proposed to use an indicator of the average voltage between body and electrode that is extracted directly from the sense electrode signal by a post-processing method. Embodiments according to this aspect are based on the insight that the sensor signal may consist of a (partly additive) mixture of electrophysiological signals and motion induced signals. Furthermore, the electrophysiological signal of interest and the motion-induced signals are assumed to be statistically independent, which is reasonable for at least ECG and EEG signals. The indicator provides a means to obtain feedback on the effectiveness of motion artifact reduction and is used to actively control the average voltage.
(115) The statistical independence of the motion-induced signal from the electrophysiological signal can be increased artificially by mechanically mounting the sensor to its housing via an elastic object (see for example
(116) The block diagram in
(117) Optionally, motion-induced variations in the transfer of the electrophysiological signal (S(f)V.sub.BIO) giving rise to a multiplicative motion artifact may be compensated using neutralization to reduce these type of motion artifacts. These techniques can be combined with the below described embodiments in accordance with implementations of the invention.
(118) In accordance with one or more of the embodiments an adaptive power minimization is provided. Typically, at least ECG and EEG signals show persistence and regularity over time, and the average signal powers vary only very gradually. The sensor signal consists of an additive mixture of electrophysiological signals and motion induced signals, therefore the average power of the DC-free signal also provides an indication of the average voltage between body and electrode. When the compensation signal {circumflex over (V)}.sub.AV is varied, a certain value P.sub.min exists for which the sensor signal power P and thus the motion-induced signal is minimized, as visualized in
(119) Iterative optimization algorithms, such as gradient descent provide a straightforward method to adapt the compensation signal in order to achieve minimization of the sensor signal power P (t). A typical scheme for updating the compensation signal {circumflex over (V)}.sub.AV from t=t.sub.0 to t=t.sub.1, is given by
(120)
where the adaptation constant controls the convergence speed and the steady-state noise. The gradient descent method shown here merely serves as an example, since any iterative optimization algorithm can be applied.
(121) A straightforward method to obtain an estimate of the gradient is by finite difference approximation, i.e.
(122)
where it is assumed that the compensation signal values at t.sub.0 and t.sub.1 are not equal. Other methods based on modulation or wobbling can also be applied to determine the local gradient.
(123) In the above embodiments, the average power of the sensor signal is used as the minimization criterion. Alternatively, the sensor signal can be pre-filtered, such that only a certain frequency band is used for which the power is determined. Depending on the practical application, this alternative approach can provide better separation of electrophysiological signals and motion-induced signals and increase the robustness of the method.
(124) In accordance with one or more other embodiments, an adaptive Shannon entropy minimization is used. The Shannon entropy quantifies the average information content in a signal. The sensor signal consists of an additive mixture of electrophysiological signals and motion induced signals, and entropy minimization by adapting {circumflex over (V)}.sub.AV provides a means to reduce motion artifacts. The information entropy is determined by the probability mass function p (x) of the signal, i.e.
(125)
where the base of the logarithm, e.g. e, 2, or 10, determines the entropy unit, which is simply a gain factor in the feedback. In practice, the data is discrete and H (X) typically is obtained from a probability mass function estimate {circumflex over (p)}(x), e.g. the histogram, therefore
(126)
(127) The lower the entropy, the more predictable is the signal, and the less information is contained. Again, iterative optimization can be applied, e.g. steepest descent, to update the compensation signal and the gradient can be obtained by e.g. finite difference approximation, so
(128)
(129) Note that algorithms based on other information-theoretic measures, such as negentropy, non-Gaussianity, etc. can also be used as an indicator of the independent components in the signal.
(130) In the following, embodiments will be described which can be used alone or in arbitrary combination with other embodiments as described or shown above or below.
(131) An adaptive probe transfer equalization for capacitive sensing of biosignals is proposed.
(132) As mentioned above, motion-induced artifacts are induced where the coupling capacitance is changing due to skin-electrode distance variation induced by movements of the test subject, causing deterioration of the measured electrophysiological signal. This problem becomes larger in applications where the measurements are performed on free-moving subjects.
(133)
(134)
where V.sub.bio is the electrophysiological signal of interest. It can be seen that variations in C.sub.e as a result of motion cause variations in the transfer V.sub.o/V.sub.bio, which degrade the measurement. A transfer that is independent of C.sub.e can be obtained by actively shielding C.sub.I i.e. making C.sub.i virtually zero, resulting in a transfer V.sub.o/V.sub.bio equal to one. This can be done as shown in the embodiment of
(135) The embodiment of
(136) Feeding back the correct amount of current I.sub.f can be achieved using the circuit in
(137) The required output voltage V.sub.f of buffer 90 A.sub.2 can be determined from the values of the capacitors 87, 91 and the notion that the gain of the buffer equals one, such that the voltage on the positive input of the buffer 88 equals V.sub.o. Hence
(138)
(139) Furthermore, the output signal of buffer 90, A.sub.2, is applied to a controllable series resistor divider 92 (R2), 93 (R1) connected in series between the output of buffer 90 and ground or reference potential 94. The output signal of buffer 90 is given by
(140)
(141) Hence, assuming fixed R.sub.1, potentiometer R.sub.2 should be adjusted such that
(142)
(143) This solution provides buffer input capacitance compensation.
(144) Usually, a priori C.sub.i is unknown. With the solution described below, it is not necessary to adjust the potentiometer 92 for each probe manufactured, which is a time-consuming and therefore expensive process. Moreover, C.sub.i may vary during operation of the probe, for instance as a function of temperature, causing the transfer function V.sub.o/V.sub.bio to deviate from one. The measurement is independent of the probe capacitance (C.sub.e) if and only if the current flowing through the buffer input capacitance (C.sub.i) is compensated exactly. The solution avoids reduction of the robustness and accuracy of the measurement which might otherwise be caused when the transfer V.sub.o/V.sub.bio deviates from unity and as a consequence the sensitivity to motion artifacts increases. For this reason, it is an object of these embodiments of the invention to automatically and adaptively control the transfer V.sub.o/V.sub.bio, such that equalization is achieved even though the characteristics of the electronics drift.
(145)
(146) Equalization may be achieved using the shown feedback control loop. The reference signal is picked up by the capacitive sensor 96 and amplified with a factor that is ideally one, but initially lower than that. The applied reference signal is then subtracted, via subtracter 101 from the measured and buffered reference signal, such that, if the total amplification is smaller than one, the result of this subtraction still contains some of the reference signal. This signal is demodulated, by multiplier 102 using the same frequency as that applied to the multiplier 99, and low pass filtered, such that we obtain a DC signal indicative of the deviation of the amplification from one. This signal is finally used to control the amplification. For that purpose the obtained DC signal is applied to an integrator 103, amplified by amplifier 104 and subsequently used by multiplier 97 to control the amount of signal that is fed back from the output of buffer amplifier 88 via a feedback capacitor 91 (C.sub.f) in order to set the amplification equal to unity. The employment of an integrator 103 means that the control loop will continue to change the feedback current until the steady state error is zero, i.e. the signal at the output of the buffer amplifier 88 is equal to the reference signal applied. In other words, its gain is equal to one. The signal of interest, i.e. V.sub.bio is now present at the output of the subtracter 101. Note that the modulation signal is not restricted to a sinusoidal, as is shown in
(147)
(148) Note that the modulation and demodulation can be implemented as a multiplier, as is shown in
(149) Note that a so-called bleeder can provide a path to ground for any op-amp bias current. The resistance does not influence the working of the circuit and can be omitted in a practical implementation.
(150) In the simulation a reference signal of amplitude 1 V and frequency 10 kHz was used. The bio signal was chosen to have amplitude of 0.1 V and a frequency of 100 Hz.
(151) A change in C.sub.e was furthermore simulated by closing switch U.sub.3 at t=0.05 s, such that at that time C.sub.e changes from 10 pF to 20 pF. It can be seen from
(152) Evidently, the bandwidth and the gain determine the convergence and tracking speed, but also the accuracy equalization. Specific settings can be tuned to the probe design and application requirements.
(153) In a further embodiment, which is shown in
(154) In another embodiment, shown in
(155) In a further embodiment, the equalization scheme is implemented in the digital domain, as visualized in
(156) In some embodiments described above, it is proposed to actively control the average voltage between the body and electrode such that the electric field between body and electrode and thus the motion-induced signal are minimized. Further, it is proposed to extract an indicator of such voltage, directly from the sensed electrode signal, and use that indicator to control a compensation signal. The proposed post-processing methods exploit the statistical independence of the motion-induced signals and the electrophysiological signal of interest. Since the mixture is partly additive, the indicator used may optionally equal the average sensor signal power and the compensation signal is controlled such that the average power is minimized.
(157) In the embodiments described below, it is proposed to actively control the average voltage between the body and electrode to minimize the motion-induced signal. Another manner of deriving the compensation signal is provided. In these embodiments it is proposed to reconstruct the input signal using the measured variation of the capacitance of the electrode and derive the compensation signal from further processing the reconstructed signal. Furthermore, since the variation of the electrode capacitance is known, the modulating effect of the time-varying capacitance on the electrophysiological signal can be removed. The parameters of the capacitive sensing circuit, such as the load (R), the stray capacitance (C.sub.i) are known or can be estimated.
(158) In the embodiment of
(159)
(160) The variation of the electrode capacitance (C.sub.e(t)) can be measured, for instance, by using a known signal injection technique. The inserted voltage V.sub.Ins may be a carrier wave at a frequency F.sub.c much larger than the frequencies of interest in the input signal. At the output, this carrier is modulated by a time-dependent factor C.sub.e(t)/(C.sub.i+C.sub.e(t)), which allows for the reconstruction of C.sub.e(t). This method to estimate the time-varying capacitance (C.sub.e(t)) may also be replaced by another suitable method.
(161) In the following a method to derive V.sub.in and compensation signal will be described, as implemented in block 126.
(162) The output signal V.sub.o in
(163)
Equation (1) can be rewritten as follows
(164)
(165) Hence V.sub.in can be reconstructed if V.sub.o(t), C.sub.e(t), R, C.sub.i, and Q.sub.init are known.
(166) Q.sub.init may be estimated, for instance, by assuming that the correlation between the time-varying part of 1/C.sub.e(t) and V.sub.in(t), equals zero, i.e.,
(167)
for a suitable value of T. This yields a linear equation in Q.sub.init.
This procedure is equivalent to choosing Q.sub.init. such that the signal power
(168)
is minimized.
(169) The compensation signal is then derived from the average of the reconstructed V.sub.in.
(170) Note that the DC-offset can be of the order of volts, whereas the biosignal to be measured is typically of the order of millivolts. This means that a small relative error in the above calculation of Q.sub.init would still give a large relative error in the reconstructed signal. This is the reason why active compensation, i.e., reducing the DC-offset by the compensation signal, is provided.
(171) Applications of embodiments of the invention include any application in which electrophysiological fields (ECG, EMG, EEG, EOG, EHG, . . . ) are probed or sensed. Any one of such applications are potential candidates where capacitive sensors such as the sensors disclosed in the present specification and drawings can be applied. Some examples where capacitive sensors can be used are patient monitors (mostly ECG), EEG probing device (clinical), brain computer interface (BCI), pregnancy belts containing sensors for monitoring baby condition or uterine activity, EMG probing device to monitor muscle use in order to prevent muscle overload or RSI, device that monitors ECG or EMG during physical activity/sports or devices that interpret emotions based on electrophysiological signals. Since capacitive sensors have the unique capability to measure through insulating materials new possibilities arise like measuring through bandages, e.g. in case of burn wounds or measure electrophysiological signals in a smart bed.
(172) Embodiments may for example be applied in the patient monitoring sector, optionally with capacitive sensors having sufficient robustness. Further, embodiments may be used in the field of home monitoring in which user friendly probing of body vital signs (e.g. the ECG) is beneficial.
(173) Embodiments in accordance with the invention may be applied for medical and healthcare devices, CE products and other applications where electrophysiological signal (e.g., ECG, EMG, EEG and etc.) measurements, especially by means of contactless (capacitive coupling), are performed. As an example embodiments may be used for smart beds providing a platform for measurements e.g. during the night.
(174) Other variations to the disclosed embodiments can be understood and effected by those skilled in the art in practicing the claimed invention, from a study of the drawings, the disclosure, and the appended claims.
(175) In the claims, the word comprising does not exclude other elements or steps, and the indefinite article a or an does not exclude a plurality.
(176) A single unit or device may fulfill the functions of several items recited in the claims. The mere fact that certain measures are recited in mutually different dependent claims does not indicate that a combination of these measures cannot be used to advantage.
(177) Features recited in separate embodiments or dependent claims may be advantageously combined in any arbitrary combination.
(178) While the invention has been illustrated and described in detail in the drawings and foregoing description, such illustration and description are to be considered illustrative or exemplary and not restrictive; the invention is not limited to disclosed embodiments. For example, it is possible to operate the invention in an embodiment for measuring other signals such as non-biological signals.
(179) Any reference signs in the claims should not be construed as limiting the scope.
(180) Calculations, processes, steps, and determinations performed by one or several units or devices can be performed by any other number of units or devices. For example, the method steps can be performed by a single unit of by any other number of different units. The calculations and determinations and/or the control of the system and/or of the device in accordance with the above described methods can be implemented as program code means of a computer program and/or as dedicated hardware.
(181) A computer program may be stored/distributed on a suitable medium, such as an optical storage medium or a solid-state medium, supplied together with or as part of other hardware, but may also be distributed in other forms, such as via the Internet or other wired or wireless telecommunication systems.