Nanoporous bioelectrochemical sensors for measuring redox potential in biological samples
10969379 · 2021-04-06
Assignee
- The Regents Of The University Of Michigan (Ann Arbor, MI)
- Virginia Commonwealth University (Richmond, VA)
Inventors
- Rodney C. Daniels (Plymouth, MI, US)
- Kevin R. Ward (Superior Township, MI, US)
- Maryanne M. Collinson (Richmond, VA, US)
Cpc classification
G01N27/3277
PHYSICS
B01L2200/12
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L3/502707
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
G01N27/3278
PHYSICS
G01N27/3272
PHYSICS
B01L2300/12
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
B01L3/502715
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
International classification
G01N27/327
PHYSICS
B01L3/00
PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
Abstract
A bioelectrochemical sensor utilizing a nanoporous gold electrode. The bioelectrochemical sensor is suitable for measuring redox in biologic media while having increased resistance to biofouling as compared to conventional electrodes such as planar gold electrodes, due to greater exposed surface area of the three-dimensional ligature structure defining the nanopores. The nanopores have a pore size of 5-100 nm, preferably with an average pore size of less than 50 nm, and more preferably with an average pore size of less than 20 nm.
Claims
1. A bioelectrochemical sensor, comprising: a first electrode including a nanoporous precious metal, the nanoporous precious metal of the first electrode being nanoporous gold, the first electrode including a plurality of gold coated strips; an etched gold leaf disposed over a surface of the plurality of gold coated strips; a strip of TEFLON tape disposed over the etched gold leaf, the TEFLON tape having a hole therethrough positioned over the etched gold leaf; a reference electrode, the reference electrode being a silver/silver chloride electrode; and a counter electrode, the counter electrode being platinum.
2. The bioelectrochemical sensor of claim 1, in combination with a block having a microfluidic channel therein, the microfluidic channel including a portion aligned with an exposed nanoporous region of the first electrode.
3. The bioelectrochemical sensor of claim 1, the pores of the nanoporous precious metal of the first electrode having a pore size of 100 nm or less.
4. The bioelectrochemical sensor of claim 3, the nanoporous precious metal of the first electrode having an average pore size of less than 50 nm.
5. The bioelectrochemical sensor of claim 3, the nanoporous precious metal of the first electrode having an average pore size of less than 20 nm.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
(15) Although blood gas measures have long been established as a means to evaluate critical illness, they rely solely on pH and acid/base pairs in blood (proton chemistry) while the activity of the electrons has been relatively ignored (redox chemistry). It is the missing pieces, namely electron transfer and oxidation/reduction balance, that provide a more comprehensive evaluation of metabolic and oxidative stress in critical illness. Further, restoring redox balance is widely considered to be important for improving the metabolic derangements in shock. Moreover, oxidative stress is not merely a secondary phenomenon, but a central factor in driving the systemic inflammatory response leading to multiple organ failure. Due to a lack of reliable methods to directly measure blood redox state, it was necessary to rely upon secondary measures (such as lactate and SvO.sub.2) to assess whether a patient is in oxidative stress. However, given the prevalence of sepsis and other adverse affects of oxidative stress, in patients having normal vital signs and stable secondary measures lactate and SvO.sub.2, it would be desirable to supplement or even replace those secondary measurements with the methodologies described herein for directly evaluating changes in redox balance, in real time. In other words, with a better understanding and calibration of the association of redox balance with shock and progression to organ dysfunction, redox can be developed as a viable biomarker for shock, resuscitation (including fluid and transfusion requirements), regulation of coagulation, and organ dysfunction in critical illness and injury, as well as other disease states. Such tools can even be considered for continuous monitoring of harvested organs to improve preservations by monitoring the organ itself and organ preservation media.
(16) One advantage of measuring redox balance to monitor metabolic and oxidative stress is that it directly reflects three biochemical states: pH, electron transfer, and oxidation-reduction reactions. Although blood gas measures have long been established as a means to evaluate critical illness, they rely solely on pH and acid/base pairs in blood (proton chemistry), ignoring the electrons and reactive oxygen species that provide a more comprehensive evaluation of metabolic and oxidative stress in critical illness. However, conventional redox sensors were too susceptible to biofouling to be effective for clinically-significant data collection or patient monitoring. By increasing the surface area of the precious metal or other active material of the working electrode through which the balance of oxidants and reductants in a biologic media (such as blood, plasma, urine breath condensate, or tissue interstitium) is measured in a redox sensor, the sensor's resistance to biofouling is increased.
(17) The bioelectrochemical redox sensors of the present disclosure utilize high surface area, nanostructured electrodes. In particular, through the formation of nanopores throughout the surface of a precious metal, such as gold, as the working electrode of a bioelectrochemical redox sensor, with nanopores ranging from 5 to 50 mn in diameter, the resulting electrode has a surface area approximately 25 to 40 times larger than planar (flat) gold. In addition to increased resistance to biofouling, the nanoporous structure of the gold electrodes enhances the resulting sensor's mass transport restriction. This mass transport restriction works by hindering large proteins from reaching the inner electrode surface, while allowing redox species and electrons access to the electrode via the nanoporous structure. Electron transfer and redox species are hindered at the planar/flat gold surface of a conventional planar gold electrode of a conventional redox sensor by interference with albumin and proteins, whereas these albumin and proteins, while still present on a nanoporous gold (np Au) electrode, are sufficiently spread out so as not to block the nanoporous matrix and therefore cannot impede electron transfer and redox species exchanging with the bioelectrochemical redox sensors of the present disclosure.
Example 1
(18) A nanoporous gold electrode suitable for use in a bioelectrochemical redox sensors of the present disclosure was prepared by etching a gold leaf, following the protocol schematically illustrated in the flow charts of
(19) In preparing a gold-coated slide to serve as an adhesion and base conduction layer for nanoporous gold, as depicted in
(20) Starting with a 10-12 K white gold leaf (Monarch brand), as depicted in
(21) The steps for finishing the nanoporous gold electrode will now be described with reference to
(22) Next, the gold coated slide carrying the nanoporous gold was removed from the deionized water bath and blotted lightly onto absorptive paper to remove excess water, then placed into a clean glass dish and allowed to dry fully.
(23) Once dry, the gold coated slide carrying the nanoporous gold was placed into ultraviolet (UV) light for three hours for further cleaning and treatment, then removed from the UV light. A ⅛-inch diameter circular punch was then punched through the center of a 0.5 inch×1 inch strip of TEFLON® tape, and the TEFLON® tape was then adhered over the UV-treated gold coated slide carrying nanoporous gold (i.e., the nanoporous gold electrode), with the center of the punch located in a center of the nanoporous gold region of the electrode. Next, TEFLON® tape was folded over the end of the electrode and the sides of the TEFLON® tape were compressed together to seal off the end of the electrode, with the exception of the previously punched out nanoporous area. Lastly, the cut ends of the TEFLON® tape were wrapped using a plastic paraffin film (PARAFILM M®) to seal a proximal portion of the nanoporous gold electrode from leakage.
(24) A silver/silver chloride (Ag/AgCl) reference electrode was formed by electroplating AgCl on a Ag wire. The diameter of the Ag/AgCl reference electrode was 1 mm. By comparison, the dimensions of the nanoporous gold electrode were about 4-5 mm×15-20 mm. The average size of the nanopores was measured using a scanning electron microscope (SEM), and the average pore size was 20-30 nm. An SEM image of the nanoporous gold electrode is provided at
(25) The surface area of the nanoporous gold electrode was measured by immersing the electrode in 0.5 M H.sub.2SO.sub.4, followed by cyclic voltammetry at 50 mV/s. The charge required to reduce the gold oxide formed during the oxidation step was measured and a conversion factor of 386 μC/cm.sup.2 used to determine the real area of the exposed region of the electrode.
Example 2
(26) A nanoporous gold electrode suitable for use in a bioelectrochemical redox sensors of the present disclosure was prepared using a co-sputter technique, following the protocol schematically illustrated in the flow chart of
(27) Glass slides were precleaned using an etching solution. These slides were then placed in the LAB 18 system. The LAB 18 system was operated according to the deposition recipe and additional parameters identified in Box 50 of
(28) Co-sputter formation of nanoporous gold electrodes provides the ability to control thickness of the electrode, which can vary based on the particular application. The greater the thickness, the greater the sensitivity of the electrode, as the thicker the electrode, the thicker the ligaments of the three-dimensional network of nanometer-sized pores and ligaments defining the nanoporous gold electrode, and thus the greater exposed surface area. However, even a relatively thin nanoporous gold electrode is acceptable for performing redox measurements on solutions, as even thin nanoporous gold electrodes are sufficiently resistant to biofouling. An SEM image of a nanoporous gold electrode produced according to the co-sputter technique with nitric acid de-alloying according to the method depicted in
(29) Turning to
(30)
(31)
Example 3
(32) To demonstrate the superiority in resistance to biofouling of nanoporous gold electrodes in biologic media as compared to conventional planar gold electrodes, cyclic voltammetry (CV) was performed on both a nanoporous gold electrode formed according to the nitric acid etching technique depicted in
Example 4
(33) The experiment of Example 3 was replicated using human whole blood instead of BSA, and similar results as depicted in
Example 5
(34) Swine were hemorrhaged to varying degrees of oxygen debt (up to 80 cc/kg) and then resuscitated. Matched redox potential measurements were then made using a nanoporous gold electrode formed according to the nitric acid etching technique depicted in
(35) There are a wide variety of potential applications of redox monitoring with bioelectrochemical redox sensors having nanoporous electrodes according to the methods, techniques, and apparatus of the present disclosure, both in vivo and ex vivo. In particular, redox measurements may be made in a wide variety of blood and biologic fluids including, but not limited to, whole blood, including plasma, serum, any other fluid component of blood; respiratory fluids and vapor, including sputum, exhaled breath condensate, bronchial alveolar lavage fluid, and condensate or exhaled volume from a ventilator circuit (for patients receiving either invasive or non-invasive mechanical ventilation; urine (either clean catch, via intermittent catheterization, or via a Foley or other indwelling catheter); cerebral spinal fluid, including fluid taken from ventricular system of the brain or other fluid collection within or surrounding the brain/skull; exudative and/or transudative fluid (from any source), including pleural fluid, peritoneal fluid, abscess or other fluid collection secondary to suspected infection, serous fluid collections from any source, or other body fluid collection. In addition, continuous or semicontinuous monitoring of these fluids and even tissue interstitium within organs themselves would be possible when biofouling is minimized.
(36) Additionally, redox measurements may be made using bioelectrochemical redox sensors according to the present disclosure in a wide variety of non-biologic fluids utilized for clinical purpose or personal health, including, but not limited to, intravenous fluids (saline, albumin, Dextrose, TPN, and combinations of these fluids+/−Electrolytes), dialysis solution utilized in peritoneal and hemodialysis as well as ultrafiltrate and fluids utilized in continuous renal replacement therapy (CRRT), pharmaceutical solutions and drugs used to treat patients (all liquid/solution preparations), and any other liquid or solution that does not erode the electrode surface (i.e. strong acids).
(37) There are a wide variety of clinical and non-clinical uses for the bioelectrochemical redox sensors according to the present disclosure, including, but not limited to, sepsis and septic shock, all forms of systemic shock (such as cardiogenic, neurogenic, distributive, septic, traumatic/hemorrhagic/burn, and hypovolemic), cardiovascular disease/heart disease; lung disease and acute lung injury, such as COPD/emphysema, asthma, pneumonia, cystic fibrosis, and acute respiratory distress syndrome, diabetes including diabetic ketoacidosis, acute and chronic kidney injury and renal disorders of all types, traumatic brain injury and other brain injured states, including epilepsy/status epilepticus and stroke, clinical oncology and hematology including sickle cell disease, gastrointestinal diseases such as inflammatory bowel diseases, pharmaceutical monitoring, trauma and burn management, monitoring of blood in blood banks for blood product viability, safety, and treatment with antioxidants, transplant organ viability and optimization, and any other condition affected by oxidative metabolism, oxidative stress, reactive oxygen species, oxygen free radicals or other biochemical/electrochemical processes that involve oxidation-reduction reactions and redox pairs.
(38) A bioelectrochemical redox sensor having a nanoporous gold electrode according to the present disclosure may be provided as a point-of-care device similar to a glucometer or bedside blood gas analyzer (e.g. i-STAT® blood gas analyzer), including a disposable microfluidic testing cartridge, such as that described in Example 2, that would contain the integrated nanoporous gold electrode coupled with a handheld potentiostat reader with an imbedded screen for result reporting. Alternately, it could transmit results to a remote display, such as a computer, a tablet, or a smartphone. As a handheld, portable device, the bioelectrochemical redox sensor device could be deployed both in and out of the hospital setting and utilized in multiple environments from the battlefield to the ICU to the general medical care setting. Additionally, a bioelectrochemical redox sensor having a nanoporous gold electrode according to the present disclosure may be provided as part of a continuous or semicontinuous device to measure redox potential of the central circulation for example as a part of a central venous or arterial catheter, as part of an extracorporeal device such as a dialysis unit, cardiopulmonary bypass, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation device, as part of a urinary catheter device for measuring urine, as part of a ventilator circuit for exhaled breath condensate, as part of a ventriulostomy device for cerebrospinal fluid, as part of an indwelling tissue probe for tissue parenchymal interstitial, as part of a tissue preservation apparatus for organ preservation, and others.
(39) Automated treatments could be devised based on measurements of redox potential employing the reliable, biofouling-resistant nanoporous gold electrode-based bioelectrochemical sensors of the present disclosure, similar to artificial pancreas or glucose/insulin management. For instance, redox measurement-based treatment systems could utilize a controller in communication with a treatment delivery device and a biofouling-resistant nanoporous gold electrode-based bioelectrochemical sensors of the present disclosure, with a feedback loop, such that the controller, in real time, continuously adjusts the treatment delivery device based on redox measurements.
(40) Given that redox measurements provide a primary and direct measure of vital clinical information, namely oxidative/metabolic stress and oxygen debt, clinicians may no longer need to rely on crude secondary measures to guide their management of patients with sepsis and septic shock. Instead, they can use redox measures as systemic or local biomarker, in real time, to identify the severity of sepsis/septic shock, evaluate the adequacy of resuscitation, guide therapeutic interventions, and monitor the patient's progress over time. By providing more accurate and rapid evaluation of the patient's condition, the redox platform may enable more accurate diagnostic evaluation and timely therapeutic intervention that could serve to improve outcomes and decrease both the health care costs and mortality associated with critical illness and injury, or any other disease processes disclosed herein.