Porous Silicon One-Wafer Battery with Voltage Enhancement by Internal Field
20180366768 ยท 2018-12-20
Inventors
Cpc classification
H01M4/5825
ELECTRICITY
Y02P70/50
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
Y02E10/50
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
H01M4/525
ELECTRICITY
H02S40/38
ELECTRICITY
H01M4/505
ELECTRICITY
Y02E60/10
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
H01M2004/021
ELECTRICITY
Y02E70/30
GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
International classification
H01M4/525
ELECTRICITY
H01M4/58
ELECTRICITY
H01M4/505
ELECTRICITY
Abstract
The invention provides methods, apparatuses, and systems that may provide an improved battery, wherein the battery includes a wafer with matrix design which provides greatly simplified construction of cells, increased energy density and power density, elimination of a separator, completely sealed cells, increased safety, and many more features. In some embodiments, to a wafer battery such as a one-wafer battery wherein the performance is increased by incorporating a p-n-junction in each pore of a wafer matrix, thus creating a porous silicon one-wafer battery with voltage enhancement by internal field.
Claims
1. A battery, comprising: a porous semiconductor material, frame or substrate providing the structure or the support for the battery active materials which include an anode, cathode and electrolyte, wherein: the anode is made of at least one of the following materials: lithium metal, lithium silicon, lithium titanate, all combinations of li-ion; the cathode is made of at least one of the following materials: cobalt oxide, manganese oxide, nickel-manganese-cobalt oxide, nickel-cobalt-aluminum oxide, iron-phosphate, silicate, etc.
2. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor does not participate in the reaction and remains unchanged during the battery operation.
3. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor provides enhanced performance by being configured in an unchanging, repeatable three-dimensional structure that enables a three-phase boundary for battery reactions, wherein the three-phase boundary signifies the point where the active battery material, electronic conductor and ionic conductor meet.
4. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor is configured to be doped with impurities to increase the electronic conductivity.
5. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor is configured to be doped with impurities to create an electrical field stretching the length of electrode thickness and enhancing the battery reaction.
6. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor is configured with a thicknesses from 50 micrometers to 1000 micrometers, wherein the preferred range the for use in the lithium-based batteries is 60-400 micrometers.
7. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor is configured with one or more pores, such that each pore has the necessary battery active materials to create a pore battery whereby then the pores are in at least one of the following configurations: the pores span from one end of the semiconductor to the other, the pores terminate at any length and remain open on one side only.
8. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor contains multiple pores connected electrically in parallel, such that each semiconductor forms a battery made up of connected pore batteries.
9. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor contains multiple pores as separate reaction sites, wherein each site forms a closed system without significant material exchange, but with electrical connection between each other.
10. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor is configured with additional layers of material, wherein the material is: conductive, the thicknesses the layers is between 1 nm to 10 micrometers, but preferably between of 20-100 nm.
11. A battery, as in claim 10 additionally comprising of: wherein the additional layers completely covers the entire surface of a semiconductor including the insides of the pores.
12. A battery, as in claim 10 additionally comprising of: wherein the additional layers are configured to create diffusion barriers between the battery active materials and the semiconductor.
13. A battery, as in claim 10 additionally comprising of: wherein the additional layers are configured to enable enhanced adhesion to the semiconductor material and to the subsequent layers.
14. A battery, as in claim 10 additionally comprising of: wherein the additional layers are configured to conduct an electrical current.
15. A battery, as in claim 10 additionally comprising of: wherein the additional layers are configured to provide a dielectric barrier layer and prevent electrical current.
16. A battery, as in claim 15 additionally comprising of: wherein the dielectric barrier layer or a passivation layers are configured to prevent an electrochemical reaction from occurring, to stop at least a reaction that forms lithium deposition and the formation of lithium dendrites on the face of the electrode.
17. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the battery is formed from one porous semiconductor containing at least one of a conductive layer and a passivation layer; wherein all the components of the battery are situated within one pore; and each pore is a closed system with no reactant or product exchange with any other pore; but all the pores in the one porous semiconductor are electrically connected in parallel to form a larger battery.
18. A battery, as in claim 1 additionally comprising of: wherein the battery is formed from two porous semiconductors containing passivation layers on one side; and assembled into a battery cell by orienting the passivation layers to face each other and therefore accomplishing separator-less construction.
19. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein non-electrically conductive materials are configured in the middle of a pore and metalized materials are at the sides of the pores.
20. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor is doped with impurities to create p-type or n-type material and whereby one p-type material is on one side of a pore and n-type material is on the other side of the pore; and whereby a pn junction is formed between the two types of material.
21. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the pores contain pn-junctions, whereby the pn-junction is removed away from the middle or off-center of the pore.
22. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the pores contain pn-junctions; and whereby the pn-junctions form an electrical field based on the junction built-in voltage, and enhance the electrical performance of battery by enhancing the cell voltage.
23. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the ends of pores are sealed with a metallic layer for conduction; and whereby wherein the battery is completely sealed and does not require additional packaging.
24. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the semiconductor is coated on the open sides of the pores, such that it is sealed, wherein the seal is metallic and connected to a metallic tab for electrically connecting the battery to the outside environment.
25. A battery, as in claim 24 additionally comprising of: wherein the seal and metallic tab is configured using a conductive paste or an ink, whereby the solvent evaporates after the application and leaves a conductive bond.
26. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein the substrate and pores are collectively sealed with metallic layers on the outside; and whereby then the exterior layer is over molded with the plastic material package, such that the battery is sealed to the exterior environment.
27. A battery, as in claim 7 additionally comprising of: wherein a pn-junction in each respective pore is exposed by a transparent window to create a photovoltaic effect that enhances the performance of a battery and can provide battery charging.
Description
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0016] Example embodiments may be illustrated by way of example and may be not limited to the figures of the accompanying drawings, in which, like references indicate similar elements.
[0017]
[0018]
[0019]
[0020]
[0021]
[0022]
[0023]
[0024]
[0025]
[0026]
[0027]
[0028]
[0029]
[0030]
[0031] Other features of the present embodiments may be apparent from the accompanying drawings and from the detailed description that follows.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0032] Disclosed may be methods, apparatus, and systems that may provide for an improved lithium battery which has reduced manufacturing costs and complexity as well as better packaging while also including higher energy density, specific energy, charge and discharge rates as well as other features such as a photovoltaic ability etc.
[0033] Neah Power Systems has previously filed U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/952,237 for use of porous silicon in lithium batteries entitled: Device and related method for assembling a battery using porous, structured silicon. This invention introduces an entirely new concept using porous silicon and may be designed for high-output lithium batteries. The invention described within this patent disclosure proposes at least to assemble both battery electrodes inside a single porous wafer. There may be numerous advantages of the proposed embodiment which may include at least greatly simplified construction of a cell, increased energy density and power density, elimination of a separator, completely sealed cells, increased safety, and many more advantages and improvements over prior arts.
[0034] In detail, an embodiment, which may be combined with any other embodiment, may include at least a one-wafer battery. The complete lithium metal battery or other battery type may be fabricated inside a single porous silicon wafer, with cylindrical pores going through the wafer. Each wafer may contain hundreds of thousands of pores and each pore may be a single battery, while all single battery pores may be connected in parallel into a complete battery. One end of the cylinder, i.e., pore may be an anode and the other end may be a cathode, with electrolyte in between.
[0035] An additional embodiment, which may be combined with any other embodiment, may include voltage enhancement by internal field. In one-wafer battery the ends of the pores may be metalized while the middle of the pores may be not. The middle of the pores may be passivated with suitable coating to prevent contact of lithium with silicon. This also separates the two sides electrically and enables battery performance. In between the two electrodes, i.e., the two sides, a p-n-junction may be built in silicon and may be located approximately between the anode and the cathode. The n-side of the junction may be on the cathode side of the cell. During the discharge when the electrons may be travelling through the external circuit powering the load and the p-n-junction field may be contributing to this electron movement towards the anode current collector. The built-in voltage may be approximately 0.7V and this may be a significant driving force for additional movement of electrons.
[0036] An additional embodiment, which may be combined with any other embodiment, may include metal paste contacts. The one-wafer battery with p-n-junction may be completely sealed with the final process of metallization on each side of the wafer. The metallic contacts may be accomplished using a metal paste with a solvent vehicle. The typical composition of the metal paste may include silver metal, glass frit, cellulose resin, solvent (pine oil and glycol ethers), and rheological modifiers and surfactants. The metal paste may be applied over the whole surface of the wafer and in the process plugs in the pores. After drying to drive the solvent off the paste solidifies making excellent metallic contact. This may be a novel method to accomplish current collection in lithium batteries.
[0037] This may be applied wherein a one-wafer battery with a similar principle is used. The silicon may be covered with metal in the electrode areas towards the pore openings and with insulator in the middle of the pores, between the electrodes. This may enhance element capable of moving electrons in the direction of the voltage difference during the discharge. This presents an effective addition to electron flow and may aid in charging or discharging abilities.
[0038] An additional embodiment, which may be combined with any other embodiment, may include compression molded package. The one-wafer battery with p-n-junction may be previously or currently completely sealed and needs very simple package, i.e., cover. This may be accomplished using a well-known process in the electronic packaging, the compression molding. The process may result in a simple, very thin battery.
[0039] In other embodiments, which may be instead of, or combined with other embodiments, the present invention may provide wherein the one-wafer batter with p-n junction is only partially sealed, such as for later processing, connecting or any other reason.
[0040] The present invention may provide wherein the package may be extremely durable and protects the one-wafer silicon battery. As such, it may be made of any material which may provide reduced degradation, as well as reduced degradation of the interior structures and materials of the battery.
[0041] These packaging structures and processes can include those commonly found in integrated circuit or MEMS packaging. Alternatively, other semiconductor packaging processes can be used, such as film lamination molding or printing molding. In some embodiments, the interior may be isolated from the ambient environment, partially isolated, or isolated in certain respects.
[0042] An additional embodiment, which may be combined with any other embodiment, the present invention may include solar charging. For applications where fast charging may be necessary the p-n-junction may be reversed to enable more efficient charging process where electrons may be going into negative electrode. The most important advantage may be the possibility to utilize the p-n-junction like in a solar cell and recharge the battery. For this, the edge of the wafer may be either not covered at all (i.e., only the faces of the wafer may be over-molded) or a thin, transparent layer may cover the edge.
[0043] This layer may enable transmission of light into the depletion region of the p-n-junction and production of current that may charge the battery. Additionally, the layer may enable the ability to gather light, or to focus the light to enable the highest possible charge ability, such that the battery may be able to be provided power. This may be provided either by the material itself, the geometry or additional materials embedded in the layer. It is noted that this may be added to any other layer.
[0044] The solar charging may provide wherein the process may provide to charge the battery, partially, fully, or provide for instance a top off charge, maintaining charge, or provide mitigation of a load on the battery.
[0045] This may then allow such that the relatively small surface area for light penetration may provide small additional current for the battery
[0046] In other embodiments, or the same embodiments, additional features may be introduced to enhance the collection of light and can be incorporated in the packaging. These include, but are not limited to: mirrors, reflective materials, photon up conversion materials, etc.
[0047] In another embodiment, the present invention may then include a construction where a thin solar PV cell may be wafer bonded to a completed one-wafer battery; or the two-wafer assembly (battery+PV cell) may be packaged using compression molding or other molding or material, wherein the construction allows for the solar PV ability but may still isolate the cell or battery from exposure to ambient, etc.
[0048] In some embodiments, which may be combined with any other embodiments, the electrolyte before mentioned and after mentioned may instead be a solid electrolyte.
[0049] In some embodiments, which may be combined with any other embodiments, the present invention may provide solid electrolyte instead of liquid electrolyte.
[0050] In some embodiments, which may be combined with any other embodiments, the solid electrolyte may include but may be not limited to solid lithium ion conductors. For instance such as Li.sub.2SP.sub.2S.sub.5, Li.sub.2SP.sub.2S.sub.5Li.sub.3PO.sub.4, LISICON or Lithium Superionic Conductor, Li3N, Li.sub.0.5La.sub.0.5TiO.sub.3, Li.sub.3La.sub.5Ta.sub.2O.sub.12, Li.sub.10GeP.sub.2S.sub.12.
[0051] In this embodiment, which may be instead of or combined with any other embodiment, the solid electrolyte may be applied using several different physical vapor deposition and chemical vapor deposition methods known to those experienced in the field. There are currently several known solid electrolyte materials for lithium batteries: Li.sub.2SP.sub.2S.sub.5, Li.sub.2SP.sub.2S.sub.5Li.sub.3PO.sub.4, LISICON, Li.sub.3N, Li.sub.0.5La.sub.0.5TiO.sub.3, Li.sub.3La.sub.5Ta.sub.2O.sub.12, or Li.sub.10GeP.sub.2S.sub.12 for instance. In an embodiment, after solid electrolyte fills part of the pore in the middle, the next step may be to deposit cathode material. This process may be also done using physical vapor deposition or other processes as well. The cathode material can be LiCoO.sub.2, Mn.sub.2O.sub.4FePO.sub.4, or some combination may be present after cathode deposition may be completed, among others.
[0052] In some embodiments, which may be combined with any other embodiments the solid electrolyte can be applied using sputtering deposition. For instance, by placing the open end of the pores in a wafer in the path of the sputtering stream in a deposition chamber.
[0053] The method, apparatus or system of this embodiment may provide where gaseous plasma may be first created and the generated ions are ejected from a source solid electrolyte material, i.e., source or target. The ions that hit the source electrolyte material may be ejected as neutral particles and travel in a straight line towards the open pores of a silicon wafer. A thin layer of electrolyte may form over the walls of a silicon wafer and establish connection with the metal layer already deposited. A large 3-phase boundary may be created along the pore walls. Because the pores are microscopic it may be possible that the electrolyte material sputtered may eventually deposit to close the pore off.
[0054] It is noted that the processes described may prevent the deposition of the cathode material deep into a pore and confine it to the cathode side of the pore, which may prevent electrical shorts. As a second benefit, the solid membrane may also act as a separator during the operation of a battery and during charging process prevent propagation of lithium dendrites, which potentially can occur from cathode to anode and of which may cause shorts.
[0055] In some embodiments, which may be combined with any other embodiments, an embodiment with a two-wafer cell, with separated electrodes may include wherein the openings of the pores in wafers that face the separator and each other may be passivated with a non-conductive coating to prevent build-up of dendrites on the electrode surfaces facing each other.
[0056] It is noted that it is possible only the opposite sides of the wafers are covered with conductive coating and the coating extends into the first part of the pores. In case of dendrite build-up on those surfaces or inside the pores the dendrites will keep bouncing inside the pores and may not protrude all the way out and towards the separator, which could lead to causing an electrical short with the opposite electrode.
[0057] Although the present embodiments have been described with reference to specific example embodiments, it may be evident that various modifications and changes may be made to these embodiments without departing from the broader spirit and scope of the various embodiments. It should be understood by one of ordinary skill in the art that the terms describing processes, products, elements, or methods may be industry terms and may refer to similar alternatives. In addition, the components shown in the figures, their connections, couples, and relationships, and their functions, may be meant to be exemplary only, and may be not meant to limit the embodiments described herein.
[0058]
[0059]
[0060]
[0061]
[0062] It is noted that in some embodiments, the present invention may be provided in instances where stacking may be provided, or wherein there may be more than one wafer. It is appreciated that the processes, methods, apparatuses and symptoms, of which are innovative and ingenious may be applied to as such.
[0063]
[0064]
[0065] The battery may be packaged by plastic compression molding process very well known in the semiconductor industry and those skilled in the art. The mold compound may be typically an epoxy resin, but many different formulations exist that may all be suitable for this application.
[0066] In some embodiments, the process involves dipping the one-wafer battery into the melted mold compound and then curing the mold. The thickness of the molded package can be controlled (<100 m). When the mold compound may be carefully selected, the stress on the wafer may be minimized.
[0067] This can be depicted in
[0068]
[0069]
[0070] As seen in
[0071]
[0072] The electrons may be also formed in the middle of the cell where the depletion zone of the p-n-junction creates a voltage difference of about 0.7 V or any other voltage difference. This may be effectively a diode or provide a similar characteristic. During the discharge, the built-in voltage element in the p-n-junction may be forward-biased. This electrical field sweeps all electrons in the vicinity and conducts them towards the n-type side electrical contacts. This process effectively increases the rate of oxidation of lithium (Li-->Li++e) through the effects of the electrical field. It may be conceivable and it can be envisioned that the built in voltage element of the p-n-junction may be connected in series with the lithium battery voltage. Hence, the total battery voltage may be expected to increase and electron flow to improve by the process.
[0073] The movement of charge in one-wafer battery may be depicted in
[0074] During the charging process the electrons coming into the negative electrode (i.e., lithium electrode) may simply travel through the electrical conductors (from the tab to face metal, to metallic coating inside the pores) and the silicon surrounding the pores may simply be seen by the electrical current of electrons as an insulator. Nothing would be different as if the silicon was not there at all and this may be the key advantage of using semiconductor properties of silicon to construct the battery.
[0075]
[0076]
[0077] While silicon may be the substrate for the electrodes and the rest of the cell it may be not exposed to lithium anywhere in the battery. Instead, silicon may be covered with metal in the electrode areas towards the pore openings and with insulator in the middle of the pores, between the electrodes. This creates a unique structure as the electrodes of a lithium battery may be joined through a special connection that may become an enhancing element capable of moving electrons in the direction of the voltage difference during the discharge. This presents an effective addition to electron flow.
[0078] During the discharge, the electrons travel through the external circuit, as a result of a potential difference, from anode to cathode and power the load. This movement of the negative charge takes place in the metallic parts of the cell: metallic coating inside the pores on the anode, metal coating at the face of the wafer on the anode side, anode metal tab, load, cathode metal tab, cathode metal layer, and metallic coating on the cathode side of the pores. At the same time, the positive charge moves as lithium ions (Li+) in the same direction (i.e., from anode to cathode), but through the electrolyte.
[0079]
[0080] During the opposite process of the battery charging, the electrons may be pushed into the negative electrode by means of a power supply. The p-n-junction in this case would be reverse-biased and would resist the influx of electrons into the silicon part of the cells, i.e., the walls of the cylindrical pores. However, this may be not expected to create any negative effects since the breakdown voltage of the p-n-junction diode may be in the excess of 14 V. During the charging process, the electrons coming into the negative electrode (i.e., lithium electrode) may simply travel through the electrical conductors (from the tab to face metal, to metallic coating inside the pores) and the silicon surrounding the pores may simply be seen by the electrical current of electrons as an insulator. Nothing would be different as if the silicon was not there at all and this may be the key advantage of using semiconductor properties of silicon to construct the battery.
[0081]
[0082]
[0083]
[0084]
[0085]
[0086] It is noted that in some embodiments, silicon may be replaced with another material that provides the same or similar properties, wherein efficiency or a characteristic of that particular material may be realized. For instance certain new compound materials may be used which provide a particular characteristic which is more beneficial than silicon.
[0087]
[0088]
[0089] In one embodiment, which may be combined with any other embodiment, the junction may be created at a position off-center.
[0090] In one embodiment, which may be combined with any other embodiment, the junction may be created at a position off-center wherein the junction may be closer to either side of the wafer. In another embodiment, there may be an asymmetrical junction closer to the cathode end of the wafer to allow for larger length of the pore to be utilized for the performance-limiting cathode material. In another embodiment, there may be an asymmetrical junction closer to the anode end of the wafer. In another embodiment, there may be a symmetrical junction such that may be an equal distance. In other embodiments, the junctions may be offset on any axis as well.
[0091] The dopant may be removed on one side (cathode) using a reactive ion etch. The meeting of the dotted and solid lines in
[0092] This reactive ion etch process 718 can create then wherein the dopant only stays in area 721 and not area 722.
[0093]
[0094]
[0095]
[0096]
[0097]
[0098] The paste may consist of a metal (typically silver), glass frit, cellulose resin, solvent, and other additives. The exact composition of the paste may be known by those experienced in the field. However, this process represents a true novelty for the battery assembly industry.
[0099] The paste may be then dried to remove the solvent, typically in a two-stage process, and it solidifies making a good electrical contact with the metallic layer inside the pores. A metal tab, which may later be the battery contact, may be applied during the process of paste cure to ensure good contact. As the next step, a vacuum may be drawn on the cell (from the cathode side) and the pores may be partially filled with electrolyte. Because the active material may be introduced into the pores afterward, enough space may be left in the pores.
[0100] Depicted in
[0101]
[0102]
[0103] Depicted in
[0104]
[0105]
[0106] Depicted in
[0107]
[0108]
[0109]
[0110]
[0111]
[0112]
[0113] It is noted that battery may then consist of a single wafer with pores, which are respectively created such that each pore includes an anode and cathode. There also may be an electrolyte, within the volume between and within the wafers. The wafers may include hundreds, thousands or more pores per square centimeter, depending on the application or embodiment, wherein then when the pores create battery cells of any number of cathode and anode pores on a single wafer, or wherein many of these wafers can be packaged together. It is noted that in other disclosures the same concept of a porous wafer battery can be described with an innovative two-wafer design, as applicable to this invention. This may include wherein the anode and cathode are similarly created on their own porous wafer, and then wherein the wafers, with their anode and cathode elements, are proximately configured such that they form an anode-cathode pair between each respective pores, creating a battery. It is noted that this is a noted alternative embodiment that takes many similar elements found herein
[0114] A number of embodiments have been described. Nevertheless, it may be understood that various modifications may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the claimed invention. In addition, the logic flows depicted in the figures do not require the particular order shown, or sequential order, to achieve desirable results. In addition, other steps may be provided, or steps may be eliminated, from the described flows, and other components may be added to, or removed from, the described systems. Accordingly, other embodiments may be within the scope of the following claims.
[0115] It may be appreciated that the various systems, methods, and apparatus disclosed herein may be embodied in a machine-readable medium and/or a machine accessible medium compatible with a data processing system (e.g., a computer system) and of which may be in any form including transitory, non-transitory or persistent data systems, as well as may be performed in any order.
[0116] The structures and modules in the figures may be shown as distinct and communicating with only a few specific structures and not others. The structures may be merged with each other, may perform overlapping functions, and may communicate with other structures not shown to be connected in the figures. Accordingly, the specification and/or drawings may be regarded in an illustrative rather than a restrictive sense.